Season by Season Episode Ranking Games Resurrected!

[The Spruce Moose]

yes i'm nicking Nauru-1's idea but a) if hasn't been on for nearly a year and b) at least its an alternative to the Hurt and Heals.
description of what you have to do from the previous thread:

It's been a long time since I last ran a game, so if enough people are interested I was thinking about doing this.

The basic setup would involve participants sending me through PM a ranking of episodes as we go through each season. We'll start of course with season 1. So you essentially are just PMing an ordered ranking of, in this case, episodes 1 through 13 based on your personal opinion. I'll probably allow a few days for submissions to roll in and I'll post the results when I can.

If you have any questions and/or would like to participate, please say so here.

so yeah send me a PM for Season 1 and i'll post results in either a week or when I stop getting replies. Who's in?

[Frightened Inmate No. 2]

I would be interested. I'll send you my episodes in a bit. Or you could just look in that new season 1 thread where I put my rankings.

[The Spruce Moose]

would be easier to work it all out if I had everything in PMs mate

[Frightened Inmate No. 2]

yeah, i'll do that. i just didn't have enough time before, but now i can.

[Professorfrink]

me too i will post in here

[homer the stonecutter]

Sounds fun, i will participate. I have already sent you my episode rankings, just wanted to let you know.

[The Spruce Moose]

sweet! that's 3 so far come on the rest of you you know you want to join in

[Financial Panther]

Yeah, but Nauru's game really died near the end. Hardly anyone participated anymore. No doubt that will happen here as well.

[Prune Tracy]

I'll participate from Season 3 to Season 10, where I've seen all the episodes.

[The Spruce Moose]

Yeah, but Nauru's game really died near the end. Hardly anyone participated anymore. No doubt that will happen here as well.

may as well give it a try though Panther lad it beats having this place full of Hurt and Heals

[Ruffles]

Sent my list

[Professorfrink]

for this thread and future ones use this list for the episodes just in case your lazy/dont know all of them

http://www.nohomers.net/showthread.p...=1#post3067917

[HerbertMcHoover]

for this thread and future ones use this list for the episodes just in case your lazy/dont know all of them

http://www.nohomers.net/showthread.p...=1#post3067917

There's better links to know all the episodes. Just look at each season's hurt and help or wikisimpsons' episode guide.

[LoyalStonecutter]

sure i'll give it a go, why not?

[The Spruce Moose]

subtle reminder that this exists and hopefully i'll get a few more lists

[MDB]

sure, I will do a list and I will send it as fast as I can

[Kid Moe]

I'll join in. I'll send you my list in a bit.

[The Spruce Moose]

last chance to get one in, i'll be doing the results tomorrow

[Professorfrink]

Oh, hey @The Spruce Moose for seasons 5-8 jsut use my blog posts about it for my entry, (it will save me time.)

[The Spruce Moose]

RESULTS ARE IN

1. Krusty Gets Busted - 131
2. Bart the General - 105
3. The Crepes of Wrath - 95
4. Bart the Genius - 94
5. Life on the Fast Lane - 85
6. Moaning Lisa - 75
7. There's No Disgrace Like Home - 74
8. Simpsons Roasting on an Open Fire - 73
9. The Telltale Head - 67
10. Some Enchanted Evening - 66
11. The Call of the Simpsons - 52
12. Homer's Night Out - 47
13. Homer's Odyssey - 37

Wow, so there we have it. Big leaps in popularity for Wrath & There's No Disgrace Like Home, a runaway leader and another way of showing us Homer's Odyssey is one of the NHC's least favourite classic episodes. On to Season 2 then!

[Infinity183]

Though I actually ranked it in my bottom half for this season, I'd still take Homer's Odyssey over Homerpalooza any day of the year.

[homer the stonecutter]

Pretty good results. I would have preferred Homers odyssey a little higher though, instead of last. (I put it last, but after an rewatch it was better than i remembered, now i consider it probably the fifth worst of the season.) Now i say Some enchanted evening, is the worst of the season, with the Call of the Simpsons, and there is no disrage like home, closely following. Krusty gets busted won though, and that is good, as its my favorite of season 1.

Too high:
Bart the genius.
The crepes of wrath.
Some enchanted evening.

Too low:
Simpsons roasting on a open fire.
Homers odyssey. (I put it last though, as i mentioned earlier)
The telltale head.
Homers night out. (Never understood the dislike for this one)


And the rest im either neutral too, or pleased with. So yeah, good list.

[The Spruce Moose]

Krusty Gets Busted was popular with pretty much everyone, its lowest position in any list was 4th!

[Professorfrink]

Here is my list:

Too Low
Crepes Of Wrath
Bart The Genius
Telltale Head

Too High

Bart The General
Moaring Lisa

[HerbertMcHoover]

1-1. Krusty Gets Busted
2-9. Bart the General
3-4. The Crepes of Wrath
4-10. Bart the Genius
5-8. Life on the Fast Lane
6-12. Moaning Lisa
7-3. There's No Disgrace Like Home
8-6. Simpsons Roasting on an Open Fire
9-5. The Telltale Head
10-2. Some Enchanted Evening
11-11. The Call of the Simpsons
12-7. Homer's Night Out
13-13. Homer's Odyssey

[Dumb or Dumber?]

The Hurt and Heal results for this season were:

1: Krusty Gets Busted
2: Bart the General
3: Bart the Genius
4: Life on the Fast Lane
5: Some Enchanted Evening
6: The Telltale Head
7: The Crepes of Wrath
8: Moaning Lisa
9: Simpsons Roasting on an Open Fire
10: The Call of the Simpsons
11: There's No Disgrace Like Home
12: Homer's Night Out
13: Homer's Odyssey

[LoyalStonecutter]

so we can send Season 2 lists now right?

[Financial Panther]

Yeah. I sent mine already.

[The Spruce Moose]

yep, go ahead and send me your lists now guys!

[The Spruce Moose]

come on guys I know I can get more Season 2 lists than this!