The Simpsons Hurt and Heal Tournament Semi Final 3

[The Spruce Moose]

the search for our 20 finalists continues. which 5 will make it through this one? you decide

Bart the Genius [10]
The Way We Was [10]
Flaming Moe's [10]
Marge vs. the Monorail [10]
The Last Temptation of Homer [10]
Who Shot Mr Burns? Part One [10]
Home Sweet Home-diddly-dum-doodily [10]
The Springfield Files [10]
Lost Our Lisa [10]
Mayored to the Mob [10]
Brother's Little Helper [10]
Trilogy of Error [10]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [10]
Special Edna [10]
The Way We Weren't [10]
The Father, The Son and the Holy Guest Star [10]
Girls Just Want to Have Sums [10]
Marge Gamer [10]
The Debarted [10]
No Loan Again, Naturally [10]
Postcards from the Wedge [10]
Homer Scissorhands [10]
The Book Job [10]

[The Spruce Moose]

Bart the Genius [10]
The Way We Was [10]
Flaming Moe's [10]
Marge vs. the Monorail [10]
The Last Temptation of Homer [11] +1
Who Shot Mr Burns? Part One [10]
Home Sweet Home-diddly-dum-doodily [10]
The Springfield Files [10]
Lost Our Lisa [10]
Mayored to the Mob [10]
Brother's Little Helper [10]
Trilogy of Error [10]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [10]
Special Edna [10]
The Way We Weren't [10]
The Father, The Son and the Holy Guest Star [10]
Girls Just Want to Have Sums [10]
Marge Gamer [10]
The Debarted [10]
No Loan Again, Naturally [10]
Postcards from the Wedge [10]
Homer Scissorhands [8] -2
The Book Job [10]

[cymek]

Bart the Genius [10]
The Way We Was [10]
Flaming Moe's [10]
Marge vs. the Monorail [10]
The Last Temptation of Homer [11]
Who Shot Mr Burns? Part One [10]
Home Sweet Home-diddly-dum-doodily [11] +1
The Springfield Files [10]
Lost Our Lisa [10]
Mayored to the Mob [10]
Brother's Little Helper [10]
Trilogy of Error [10]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [10]
Special Edna [10]
The Way We Weren't [10]
The Father, The Son and the Holy Guest Star [8] -2
Girls Just Want to Have Sums [10]
Marge Gamer [10]
The Debarted [10]
No Loan Again, Naturally [10]
Postcards from the Wedge [10]
Homer Scissorhands [8]
The Book Job [10]

[Bartesque]

Bart the Genius [10]
The Way We Was [10]
Flaming Moe's [10]
Marge vs. the Monorail [10]
The Last Temptation of Homer [11]
Who Shot Mr Burns? Part One [11] +1
Home Sweet Home-diddly-dum-doodily [11]
The Springfield Files [10]
Lost Our Lisa [10]
Mayored to the Mob [10]
Brother's Little Helper [10]
Trilogy of Error [10]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [8] -2
Special Edna [10]
The Way We Weren't [10]
The Father, The Son and the Holy Guest Star [8]
Girls Just Want to Have Sums [10]
Marge Gamer [10]
The Debarted [10]
No Loan Again, Naturally [10]
Postcards from the Wedge [10]
Homer Scissorhands [8]
The Book Job [10]

[Blobulle]

Bart the Genius [10]
The Way We Was [10]
Flaming Moe's [10]
Marge vs. the Monorail [10]
The Last Temptation of Homer [11]
Who Shot Mr Burns? Part One [11]
Home Sweet Home-diddly-dum-doodily [11]
The Springfield Files [10]
Lost Our Lisa [11] +1
Mayored to the Mob [10]
Brother's Little Helper [8] -2
Trilogy of Error [10]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [8]
Special Edna [10]
The Way We Weren't [10]
The Father, The Son and the Holy Guest Star [8]
Girls Just Want to Have Sums [10]
Marge Gamer [10]
The Debarted [10]
No Loan Again, Naturally [10]
Postcards from the Wedge [10]
Homer Scissorhands [8]
The Book Job [10]

[Zombies Rise from the Sea]

Bart the Genius [10]
The Way We Was [10]
Flaming Moe's [11] +1
Marge vs. the Monorail [10]
The Last Temptation of Homer [11]
Who Shot Mr Burns? Part One [11]
Home Sweet Home-diddly-dum-doodily [11]
The Springfield Files [10]
Lost Our Lisa [11] +1
Mayored to the Mob [10]
Brother's Little Helper [8] -2
Trilogy of Error [10]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [8]
Special Edna [10]
The Way We Weren't [10]
The Father, The Son and the Holy Guest Star [8]
Girls Just Want to Have Sums [10]
Marge Gamer [10]
The Debarted [8] -2
No Loan Again, Naturally [10]
Postcards from the Wedge [10]
Homer Scissorhands [8]
The Book Job [10]

[Financial Panther]

Bart the Genius [10]
The Way We Was [10]
Flaming Moe's [11]
Marge vs. the Monorail [10]
The Last Temptation of Homer [11]
Who Shot Mr. Burns? (Part One) [11]
Home Sweet Homediddly-dum-doodily [11]
The Springfield Files [11] +1
Lost Our Lisa [11]
Mayored to the Mob [10]
Brother's Little Helper [8]
Trilogy of Error [10]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [8]
Special Edna [10]
The Way We Weren't [10]
The Father, The Son, and the Holy Guest Star [6] -2
Girls Just Want to Have Sums [10]
Marge Gamer [10]
The Debarted [8]
No Loan Again, Naturally [10]
Postcards from the Wedge [10]
Homer Scissorhands [8]
The Book Job [10]

[huge2thadork]

Bart the Genius [10]
The Way We Was [10]
Flaming Moe's [11]
Marge vs. the Monorail [10]
The Last Temptation of Homer [12] +1
Who Shot Mr. Burns? (Part One) [11]
Home Sweet Homediddly-dum-doodily [11]
The Springfield Files [11]
Lost Our Lisa [11]
Mayored to the Mob [10]
Brother's Little Helper [8]
Trilogy of Error [10]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [8]
Special Edna [10]
The Way We Weren't [10]
The Father, The Son, and the Holy Guest Star [4] -2
Girls Just Want to Have Sums [10]
Marge Gamer [10]
The Debarted [8]
No Loan Again, Naturally [10]
Postcards from the Wedge [10]
Homer Scissorhands [8]
The Book Job [10]

[Ronster]

Bart the Genius [10]
The Way We Was [10]
Flaming Moe's [11]
Marge vs. the Monorail [11] +1
The Last Temptation of Homer [12]
Who Shot Mr. Burns? (Part One) [11]
Home Sweet Homediddly-dum-doodily [11]
The Springfield Files [11]
Lost Our Lisa [11]
Mayored to the Mob [10]
Brother's Little Helper [8]
Trilogy of Error [10]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [8]
Special Edna [10]
The Way We Weren't [10]
The Father, The Son, and the Holy Guest Star [4]
Girls Just Want to Have Sums [10]
Marge Gamer [10]
The Debarted [8]
No Loan Again, Naturally [8] -2
Postcards from the Wedge [10]
Homer Scissorhands [8]
The Book Job [10]

[Prune Tracy]

Hmm, probably my least favourite semi-final list thus far.

Bart the Genius [10]
The Way We Was [10]
Flaming Moe's [11]
Marge vs. the Monorail [11]
The Last Temptation of Homer [12]
Who Shot Mr. Burns? (Part One) [12] +1
Home Sweet Homediddly-dum-doodily [11]
The Springfield Files [11]
Lost Our Lisa [11]
Mayored to the Mob [10]
Brother's Little Helper [8]
Trilogy of Error [10]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [8]
Special Edna [10]
The Way We Weren't [10]
The Father, The Son, and the Holy Guest Star [4]
Girls Just Want to Have Sums [8] -2
Marge Gamer [10]
The Debarted [8]
No Loan Again, Naturally [8]
Postcards from the Wedge [10]
Homer Scissorhands [8]
The Book Job [10]

[Lionel Hutz]

Bart the Genius [10]
The Way We Was [10]
Flaming Moe's [12] +1
Marge vs. the Monorail [11]
The Last Temptation of Homer [12]
Who Shot Mr. Burns? (Part One) [12]
Home Sweet Homediddly-dum-doodily [11]
The Springfield Files [11]
Lost Our Lisa [11]
Mayored to the Mob [10]
Brother's Little Helper [8]
Trilogy of Error [10]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [8]
Special Edna [10]
The Way We Weren't [10]
The Father, The Son, and the Holy Guest Star [2] -2
Girls Just Want to Have Sums [8]
Marge Gamer [10]
The Debarted [8]
No Loan Again, Naturally [8]
Postcards from the Wedge [10]
Homer Scissorhands [8]
The Book Job [10]

[Alex_Of_Darkness]

Bart the Genius [8] -2
The Way We Was [10]
Flaming Moe's [12]
Marge vs. the Monorail [11]
The Last Temptation of Homer [12]
Who Shot Mr. Burns? (Part One) [12]
Home Sweet Homediddly-dum-doodily [11]
The Springfield Files [11]
Lost Our Lisa [11]
Mayored to the Mob [10]
Brother's Little Helper [8]
Trilogy of Error [10]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [8]
Special Edna [10]
The Way We Weren't [11] +1
The Father, The Son, and the Holy Guest Star [2]
Girls Just Want to Have Sums [8]
Marge Gamer [10]
The Debarted [8]
No Loan Again, Naturally [8]
Postcards from the Wedge [10]
Homer Scissorhands [8]
The Book Job [10]

[The Spruce Moose]

how can someone think Bart the Genius is weaker than the post-classics on the list?

[Brad Lascelle]

Bart the Genius [8]
The Way We Was [11] +1
Flaming Moe's [12]
Marge vs. the Monorail [11]
The Last Temptation of Homer [12]
Who Shot Mr. Burns? (Part One) [12]
Home Sweet Homediddly-dum-doodily [11]
The Springfield Files [11]
Lost Our Lisa [11]
Mayored to the Mob [10]
Brother's Little Helper [8]
Trilogy of Error [10]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [8]
Special Edna [10]
The Way We Weren't [11]
The Father, The Son, and the Holy Guest Star [0] -2
Girls Just Want to Have Sums [8]
Marge Gamer [10]
The Debarted [8]
No Loan Again, Naturally [8]
Postcards from the Wedge [10]
Homer Scissorhands [8]
The Book Job [10]

[Ruffles]

Bart the Genius [8]
The Way We Was [11]
Flaming Moe's [12]
Marge vs. the Monorail [11]
The Last Temptation of Homer [12]
Who Shot Mr. Burns? (Part One) [12]
Home Sweet Homediddly-dum-doodily [12] +1
The Springfield Files [11]
Lost Our Lisa [11]
Mayored to the Mob [10]
Brother's Little Helper [8]
Trilogy of Error [10]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [8]
Special Edna [10]
The Way We Weren't [11]
Girls Just Want to Have Sums [6] -2
Marge Gamer [10]
The Debarted [8]
No Loan Again, Naturally [8]
Postcards from the Wedge [10]
Homer Scissorhands [8]
The Book Job [10]

[Financial Panther]

how can someone think Bart the Genius is weaker than the post-classics on the list?

Voting down an episode doesn't mean we think it is the worst. Please don't jump to that conclusion.




Final List

23) The Father, The Son, and the Holy Guest Star

[Frightened Inmate No. 2]

Bart the Genius [8]
The Way We Was [11]
Flaming Moe's [12]
Marge vs. the Monorail [12] +1
The Last Temptation of Homer [12]
Who Shot Mr. Burns? (Part One) [10] -2 (It pains me to do this, but it's too much of a threat)
Home Sweet Homediddly-dum-doodily [12]
The Springfield Files [11]
Lost Our Lisa [11]
Mayored to the Mob [10]
Brother's Little Helper [8]
Trilogy of Error [10]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [8]
Special Edna [10]
The Way We Weren't [11]
Girls Just Want to Have Sums [6]
Marge Gamer [10]
The Debarted [8]
No Loan Again, Naturally [8]
Postcards from the Wedge [10]
Homer Scissorhands [8]
The Book Job [10]


My ideal 5 would be Marge vs. the Monorail, The Last Temptation of Homer, Flaming Moe's, The Springfield Files, and Home Sweet Homediddly-dum-doodily.

[Zombies Rise from the Sea]

Bart the Genius [8]
The Way We Was [12] +1
Flaming Moe's [12]
Marge vs. the Monorail [12]
The Last Temptation of Homer [12]
Who Shot Mr. Burns? (Part One) [10]
Home Sweet Homediddly-dum-doodily [12]
The Springfield Files [11]
Lost Our Lisa [11]
Mayored to the Mob [10]
Brother's Little Helper [8]
Trilogy of Error [10]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [8]
Special Edna [10]
The Way We Weren't [11]
Girls Just Want to Have Sums [4] -2
Marge Gamer [10]
The Debarted [8]
No Loan Again, Naturally [8]
Postcards from the Wedge [10]
Homer Scissorhands [8]
The Book Job [10]

[Knightboat]

Bart the Genius [8]
The Way We Was [12]
Flaming Moe's [12]
Marge vs. the Monorail [12]
The Last Temptation of Homer [12]
Who Shot Mr. Burns? (Part One) [10]
Home Sweet Homediddly-dum-doodily [12]
The Springfield Files [12] +1
Lost Our Lisa [11]
Mayored to the Mob [10]
Brother's Little Helper [8]
Trilogy of Error [10]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [8]
Special Edna [10]
The Way We Weren't [11]
Girls Just Want to Have Sums [2] -2
Marge Gamer [10]
The Debarted [8]
No Loan Again, Naturally [8]
Postcards from the Wedge [10]
Homer Scissorhands [8]
The Book Job [10]

[Sinister Burns]

Bart the Genius [8]
The Way We Was [12]
Flaming Moe's [12]
Marge vs. the Monorail [12]
The Last Temptation of Homer [12]
Who Shot Mr. Burns? (Part One) [11] +1
Home Sweet Homediddly-dum-doodily [12]
The Springfield Files [12]
Lost Our Lisa [11]
Mayored to the Mob [10]
Brother's Little Helper [8]
Trilogy of Error [10]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [8]
Special Edna [10]
The Way We Weren't [11]
Girls Just Want to Have Sums [0] -2
Marge Gamer [10]
The Debarted [8]
No Loan Again, Naturally [8]
Postcards from the Wedge [10]
Homer Scissorhands [8]
The Book Job [10]

Final List:

23) The Father, The Son, and the Holy Guest Star
22) Girls Just Want to Have Sums

[cymek]

Bart the Genius [8]
The Way We Was [12]
Flaming Moe's [12]
Marge vs. the Monorail [12]
The Last Temptation of Homer [12]
Who Shot Mr. Burns? (Part One) [11]
Home Sweet Homediddly-dum-doodily [13] +1
The Springfield Files [12]
Lost Our Lisa [11]
Mayored to the Mob [10]
Brother's Little Helper [8]
Trilogy of Error [10]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [6] -2
Special Edna [10]
The Way We Weren't [11]
Marge Gamer [10]
The Debarted [8]
No Loan Again, Naturally [8]
Postcards from the Wedge [10]
Homer Scissorhands [8]
The Book Job [10]

[Bartesque]

Bart the Genius [8]
The Way We Was [13] +1
Flaming Moe's [12]
Marge vs. the Monorail [12]
The Last Temptation of Homer [12]
Who Shot Mr. Burns? (Part One) [11]
Home Sweet Homediddly-dum-doodily [13]
The Springfield Files [12]
Lost Our Lisa [11]
Mayored to the Mob [10]
Brother's Little Helper [8]
Trilogy of Error [10]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [4] -2
Special Edna [10]
The Way We Weren't [11]
Marge Gamer [10]
The Debarted [8]
No Loan Again, Naturally [8]
Postcards from the Wedge [10]
Homer Scissorhands [8]
The Book Job [10]

[Blobulle]

Bart the Genius [8]
The Way We Was [13]
Flaming Moe's [12]
Marge vs. the Monorail [12]
The Last Temptation of Homer [12]
Who Shot Mr. Burns? (Part One) [11]
Home Sweet Homediddly-dum-doodily [13]
The Springfield Files [12]
Lost Our Lisa [12] +1
Mayored to the Mob [10]
Brother's Little Helper [6] -2
Trilogy of Error [10]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [4]
Special Edna [10]
The Way We Weren't [11]
Marge Gamer [10]
The Debarted [8]
No Loan Again, Naturally [8]
Postcards from the Wedge [10]
Homer Scissorhands [8]
The Book Job [10]

[Financial Panther]

Bart the Genius [8]
The Way We Was [13]
Flaming Moe's [12]
Marge vs. the Monorail [12]
The Last Temptation of Homer [12]
Who Shot Mr. Burns? (Part One) [11]
Home Sweet Homediddly-dum-doodily [13]
The Springfield Files [13] +1
Lost Our Lisa [10] -2
Mayored to the Mob [10]
Brother's Little Helper [6]
Trilogy of Error [10]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [4]
Special Edna [10]
The Way We Weren't [11]
Marge Gamer [10]
The Debarted [8]
No Loan Again, Naturally [8]
Postcards from the Wedge [10]
Homer Scissorhands [8]
The Book Job [10]

[The Spruce Moose]

Bart the Genius [8]
The Way We Was [13]
Flaming Moe's [12]
Marge vs. the Monorail [13] +1
The Last Temptation of Homer [12]
Who Shot Mr. Burns? (Part One) [11]
Home Sweet Homediddly-dum-doodily [13]
The Springfield Files [13]
Lost Our Lisa [10]
Mayored to the Mob [10]
Brother's Little Helper [6]
Trilogy of Error [10]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [2] -2
Special Edna [10]
The Way We Weren't [11]
Marge Gamer [10]
The Debarted [8]
No Loan Again, Naturally [8]
Postcards from the Wedge [10]
Homer Scissorhands [8]
The Book Job [10]

[Prune Tracy]

Bart the Genius [8]
The Way We Was [13]
Flaming Moe's [12]
Marge vs. the Monorail [13]
The Last Temptation of Homer [12]
Who Shot Mr. Burns? (Part One) [12] +1
Home Sweet Homediddly-dum-doodily [13]
The Springfield Files [13]
Lost Our Lisa [10]
Mayored to the Mob [10]
Brother's Little Helper [6]
Trilogy of Error [10]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [2]
Special Edna [10]
The Way We Weren't [11]
Marge Gamer [8] -2
The Debarted [8]
No Loan Again, Naturally [8]
Postcards from the Wedge [10]
Homer Scissorhands [8]
The Book Job [10]

[Ronster]

Bart the Genius [8]
The Way We Was [13]
Flaming Moe's [12]
Marge vs. the Monorail [14] +1
The Last Temptation of Homer [12]
Who Shot Mr. Burns? (Part One) [12]
Home Sweet Homediddly-dum-doodily [13]
The Springfield Files [13]
Lost Our Lisa [10]
Mayored to the Mob [10]
Brother's Little Helper [6]
Trilogy of Error [10]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [2]
Special Edna [10]
The Way We Weren't [11]
Marge Gamer [8]
The Debarted [8]
No Loan Again, Naturally [6] -2
Postcards from the Wedge [10]
Homer Scissorhands [8]
The Book Job [10]

[Alex_Of_Darkness]

Bart the Genius [8]
The Way We Was [13]
Flaming Moe's [12]
Marge vs. the Monorail [14]
The Last Temptation of Homer [12]
Who Shot Mr. Burns? (Part One) [12]
Home Sweet Homediddly-dum-doodily [13]
The Springfield Files [14] +1
Lost Our Lisa [10]
Mayored to the Mob [10]
Brother's Little Helper [6]
Trilogy of Error [10]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [2]
Special Edna [8] -2
The Way We Weren't [11]
Marge Gamer [8]
The Debarted [8]
No Loan Again, Naturally [6]
Postcards from the Wedge [10]
Homer Scissorhands [8]
The Book Job [10]

[Lionheart]

Bart the Genius [8]
The Way We Was [13]
Flaming Moe's [12]
Marge vs. the Monorail [15] +1
The Last Temptation of Homer [12]
Who Shot Mr. Burns? (Part One) [12]
Home Sweet Homediddly-dum-doodily [13]
The Springfield Files [14]
Lost Our Lisa [10]
Mayored to the Mob [10]
Brother's Little Helper [4] -2
Trilogy of Error [10]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [2]
Special Edna [8]
The Way We Weren't [11]
Marge Gamer [8]
The Debarted [8]
No Loan Again, Naturally [6]
Postcards from the Wedge [10]
Homer Scissorhands [8]
The Book Job [10]

[Lionel Hutz]

Bart the Genius [8]
The Way We Was [13]
Flaming Moe's [13] +1
Marge vs. the Monorail [15]
The Last Temptation of Homer [12]
Who Shot Mr. Burns? (Part One) [12]
Home Sweet Homediddly-dum-doodily [13]
The Springfield Files [14]
Lost Our Lisa [10]
Mayored to the Mob [10]
Brother's Little Helper [4]
Trilogy of Error [10]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [2]
Special Edna [8]
The Way We Weren't [11]
Marge Gamer [8]
The Debarted [8]
No Loan Again, Naturally [6]
Postcards from the Wedge [8] -2
Homer Scissorhands [8]
The Book Job [10]