The Simpsons Hurt and Heal Tournament: Season 15

[Alex_Of_Darkness]

Treehouse of Horror XIV [5]
My Mother the Carjacker [9] +1
I, D'oh-bot [18]
Simple Simpson [14]
The Way We Weren't [17]
Fraudcast News [11] -2

[The Spruce Moose]

yeah...just so you know, I really will Hulk out if My Mother the Carjacker goes through

[bomberswarm2]

How are the semis gonna work anyway? When you say draw, what do you mean exactly? Are you randomly putting bunches of episodes in brackets? I could save a list of all who moved on easily enough if you're afraid you'll lose yours.

Make 4 pools. Top episode from each season in the first pool, second best in pool 2 and so on.
Also I think you should do one for worst episode of all time. Take the first episode eliminated from each season. Reverse the scoring. You add 1 to the one you dislike the most, take away 2 from your favioruite. Last remaining episode is the worst ever!

[Oh, that's raspberry!]

I trust Spruce Moose, this was his idea anyway, his method seems fine.

[The Spruce Moose]

thank you, although I will steal Bomberswarm's idea of a tournament for worst episode ever unless he wants to do that one

[bomberswarm2]

thank you, although I will steal Bomberswarm's idea of a tournament for worst episode ever unless he wants to do that one

Oh I so wanna do that can I?

[Oh, that's raspberry!]

That wouldn't be possible until Season 23's tournament here is done, but it sounds like it could be fun.

[The Spruce Moose]

It's all yours bomberswarm, i'll probably be fed up of the wrong results coming up repeatedly by then

[ANdre1001]

Treehouse of Horror XIV [6] +1
My Mother the Carjacker [7] -2
I, D'oh-bot [18]
Simple Simpson [14]
The Way We Weren't [17]
Fraudcast News [11] -2

[Lionel Hutz]

Treehouse of Horror XIV [6]
My Mother the Carjacker [8] +1
I, D'oh-bot [18]
Simple Simpson [12] -2
The Way We Weren't [17]
Fraudcast News [11]

[bomberswarm2]

That wouldn't be possible until Season 23's tournament here is done, but it sounds like it could be fun.

This has nothing todo with much, but I just looked at page 1. You seriously think that MDLHAM is the worst of the season? Worse than BMB and MHT?

[Oh, that's raspberry!]

No, but I purposely went after it first because I knew others would take care of the worse episodes and I feared it might make it into the Top 4, which I successfully avoided. I explained it on the previous page.

[leprechaun_dan]

Since two of my favourites this season have gone, I now hope the final four will be: #1 The Way We Weren't #2 Simple Simpson #3 I D'oh-Bot and #4 My Mother the Carjacker. Fraudcast News, while a pretty good episode, should definitely not be this far ahead in this tournament

Treehouse of Horror XIV [6]
My Mother the Carjacker [8]
I, D'oh-bot [18]
Simple Simpson [12]
The Way We Weren't [18] +1
Fraudcast News [9] -2

[Zombies Rise from the Sea]

Treehouse of Horror XIV [6]
My Mother the Carjacker [8]
I, D'oh-bot [18]
Simple Simpson [10] -2
The Way We Weren't [18]
Fraudcast News [10] +1

[Safety Inspector]

Treehouse of Horror XIV [4] -2
My Mother the Carjacker [8]
I, D'oh-bot [18]
Simple Simpson [10] -2
The Way We Weren't [18]
Fraudcast News [11] + 1

Without 'Tis The Fifteenth Season Top4 will be pretty weak...
I still can't believe than people don't love this magnificent episode. Agree with Rapsberry- it's the best Jean episode ever.

[Oh, that's raspberry!]

I never said it was the best Jean episode, but certainly high up on the list.

[cymek]

Treehouse of Horror XIV [2] -2
My Mother the Carjacker [8]
I, D'oh-bot [18]
Simple Simpson [10]
The Way We Weren't [18]
Fraudcast News [12] +1

[Oh, that's raspberry!]

Treehouse of Horror XIV [2]
My Mother the Carjacker [6] -2
I, D'oh-bot [18]
Simple Simpson [11] +1
The Way We Weren't [18]
Fraudcast News [12]

[Bartesque]

Treehouse of Horror XIV [0] -2
My Mother the Carjacker [6]
I, D'oh-bot [18]
Simple Simpson [12] +1
The Way We Weren't [18]
Fraudcast News [12]

[Lionheart]

My Mother the Carjacker [7] +1
I, D'oh-bot [18]
Simple Simpson [12]
The Way We Weren't [18]
Fraudcast News [10] -2

[Prune Tracy]

My Mother the Carjacker [8] +1
I, D'oh-bot [16] -2
Simple Simpson [12]
The Way We Weren't [18]
Fraudcast News [10]

[The Spruce Moose]

My Mother the Carjacker [6] -2
I, D'oh-bot [16]
Simple Simpson [12]
The Way We Weren't [18]
Fraudcast News [11] +1 i'm not happy The Way We Weren't is going to make it, but it's still better than My Mother the Carjacker

[Brad Lascelle]

I agree completely with The Spruce Moose on this one. Our bad for not targeting The Way We Weren't early on.

My Mother the Carjacker [4] -2
I, D'oh-bot [16]
Simple Simpson [12]
The Way We Weren't [18]
Fraudcast News [12] +1

[Financial Panther]

My Mother the Carjacker [2] -2
I, D'oh-bot [17] +1
Simple Simpson [12]
The Way We Weren't [18]
Fraudcast News [12]

[Spielbergo]

My Mother the Carjacker [0] -2
I, D'oh-bot [18] +1
Simple Simpson [12]
The Way We Weren't [18]
Fraudcast News [12]

[Lionel Hutz]

At least I D'oh-Bot made it.

[Bartesque]

I'm pretty happy with the four episodes that have made it, especially I, D'oh-bot, since I was always a fan of stuff like Robot Wars/Battlebots back in the day. The other three are decent, even though Tis The Fifteenth Season could have been in the top 4.

[Oh, that's raspberry!]

Final List:

22) Bart-Mangled Banner
21) Today, I Am a Clown
20) The Ziff Who Came to Dinner
19) Co-Dependent's Day
18) The Regina Monologues
17) Catch 'Em if You Can
16) My Big Fat Geek Wedding
15) Margical History Tour
14) The President Wore Pearls
13) Marge vs. Singles, Seniors, Childless Couples and Teens, and Gays
12) Smart and Smarter
11) Milhouse Doesn't Live Here Anymore
10) 'Tis the Fifteenth Season
9) The Wandering Juvie
8) The Fat and the Furriest
7) Diatribe of a Mad Housewife
6) Treehouse of Horror XIV
5) My Mother the Carjacker
4) Simple Simpson
4) Fraudcast News
1) I, D'oh-bot
1) The Way We Weren't

[Nauru-1]

Fifteenth Season should have been there for sure, but it's a solid final four otherwise.

[Prune Tracy]

Pretty solid outcome, one of the best in a while. Three out of my Top 4 made it.