The Simpsons Hurt and Heal Tournament: Season 13

[Lionheart]

Treehouse of Horror XII [13]
The Blunder Years [3]
Jaws Wired Shut [7]
Half-Decent Proposal [11] +1
The Bart Wants What It Wants [10]
The Old Man and the Key [4] -2
Tales from the Public Domain [13]
Weekend at Burnsie's [8]
I Am Furious (Yellow) [19]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [9]
Poppa's Got a Brand New Badge [13]

[Prune Tracy]

Treehouse of Horror XII [13]
The Blunder Years [1] -2 (FFS, DIE already)
Jaws Wired Shut [8] +1
Half-Decent Proposal [11]
The Bart Wants What It Wants [10]
The Old Man and the Key [4]
Tales from the Public Domain [13]
Weekend at Burnsie's [8]
I Am Furious (Yellow) [19]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [9]
Poppa's Got a Brand New Badge [13]

[Nauru-1]

Treehouse of Horror XII [13]
The Blunder Years [1]
Jaws Wired Shut [8]
Half-Decent Proposal [12] +1
The Bart Wants What It Wants [10]
The Old Man and the Key [4]
Tales from the Public Domain [11] -2
Weekend at Burnsie's [8]
I Am Furious (Yellow) [19]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [9]
Poppa's Got a Brand New Badge [13]

[zach]

Treehouse of Horror XII [13]
The Blunder Years [2] +1
Jaws Wired Shut [8]
Half-Decent Proposal [12]
The Bart Wants What It Wants [10]
The Old Man and the Key [4]
Tales from the Public Domain [11]
Weekend at Burnsie's [8]
I Am Furious (Yellow) [17] -2
Little Girl in the Big Ten [9]
Poppa's Got a Brand New Badge [13]

[leprechaun_dan]

Treehouse of Horror XII [13]
The Blunder Years [2]
Jaws Wired Shut [8]
Half-Decent Proposal [12]
The Bart Wants What It Wants [10]
The Old Man and the Key [2] -2
Tales from the Public Domain [11]
Weekend at Burnsie's [8]
I Am Furious (Yellow) [17]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [10] +1
Poppa's Got a Brand New Badge [13]

[Lionel Hutz]

Treehouse of Horror XII [13]
The Blunder Years [2]
Jaws Wired Shut [6] -2
Half-Decent Proposal [12]
The Bart Wants What It Wants [10]
The Old Man and the Key [2]
Tales from the Public Domain [11]
Weekend at Burnsie's [8]
I Am Furious (Yellow) [17]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [10]
Poppa's Got a Brand New Badge [14] +1

[Safety Inspector]

Treehouse of Horror XII [13]
The Blunder Years [2]
Jaws Wired Shut [6]
Half-Decent Proposal [12]
The Bart Wants What It Wants [10]
The Old Man and the Key [2]
Tales from the Public Domain [12] +1
Weekend at Burnsie's [8]
I Am Furious (Yellow) [17]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [8] -2
Poppa's Got a Brand New Badge [14] +1

[Brad Lascelle]

Treehouse of Horror XII [13]
The Blunder Years [2]
Jaws Wired Shut [6]
Half-Decent Proposal [12]
The Bart Wants What It Wants [10]
The Old Man and the Key [0] -2
Tales from the Public Domain [12]
Weekend at Burnsie's [8]
I Am Furious (Yellow) [17]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [9] +1
Poppa's Got a Brand New Badge [14]

[Oh, that's raspberry!]

Damn, I knew The Old Man and the Key was underrated but I didn't know by this much. Seeing it out before The Blunder Years is pretty bad....

[leprechaun_dan]

I'll admit The Old Man and the Key is underrated and actually pretty good, but this is about the right time where it should be eliminated

Final List:

22. Gump Roast
21. The Frying Game
20. The Parent Rap
19. She of Little Faith
18. The Lastest Gun in the West
17. The Sweetest Apu
16. Sweets and Sour Marge
15. Brawl in the Family
14. Blame It On Lisa
13. Homer the Moe
12. A Hunka Hunka Burns in Love
11. The Old Man and the Key

[Oh, that's raspberry!]

You could make an argument that most episodes remaining are on par with it, not that I'd agree necessarily, but The Blunder Years for damn sure isn't and I feel confident in saying neither are the two trilogy episodes.

[leprechaun_dan]

I agree that Public Domain and THOH XII are worse than Old Man and the Key but eh, I sorta... kinda... maybe liked Blunder Years

[Blobulle]

Treehouse of Horror XII [13]
The Blunder Years [2]
Jaws Wired Shut [6]
Half-Decent Proposal [12]
The Bart Wants What It Wants [10]
Tales from the Public Domain [10] -2
Weekend at Burnsie's [8]
I Am Furious (Yellow) [17]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [10] +1
Poppa's Got a Brand New Badge [14]

[Handsome B. Wonderful]

Blunder Years is on its last leg, kick it while it's down!

[Prune Tracy]

Somebody kill it before it gets bumped up again.

[Spielbergo]

Treehouse of Horror XII [13]
The Blunder Years [2]
Jaws Wired Shut [6]
Half-Decent Proposal [12]
The Bart Wants What It Wants [10]
Tales from the Public Domain [10]
Weekend at Burnsie's [8]
I Am Furious (Yellow) [18] +1
Little Girl in the Big Ten [8] -2
Poppa's Got a Brand New Badge [14]

[cloneasaurus]

The Old Man and the Key is just plain fun, and it was eliminated before Tales of the Public Domain (??!!), THOH (forgettable), and meh episodes like Burnsies, Wants and Jaws Wired Shut? I guess it is underrated.

Treehouse of Horror XII [13]
The Blunder Years [0] -2
Jaws Wired Shut [6]
Half-Decent Proposal [12]
The Bart Wants What It Wants [10]
Tales from the Public Domain [10]
Weekend at Burnsie's [8]
I Am Furious (Yellow) [18]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [9] +1
Poppa's Got a Brand New Badge [14]

[Bartesque]

Treehouse of Horror XII [14] +1
Jaws Wired Shut [6]
Half-Decent Proposal [12]
The Bart Wants What It Wants [10]
Tales from the Public Domain [10]
Weekend at Burnsie's [8]
I Am Furious (Yellow) [18]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [7] -2
Poppa's Got a Brand New Badge [14]

[Oh, that's raspberry!]

Treehouse of Horror XII [14]
Jaws Wired Shut [6]
Half-Decent Proposal [12]
The Bart Wants What It Wants [10]
Tales from the Public Domain [8] -2
Weekend at Burnsie's [8]
I Am Furious (Yellow) [19] +1
Little Girl in the Big Ten [7]
Poppa's Got a Brand New Badge [14]

[Léo Pard]

Treehouse of Horror XII [14]
Jaws Wired Shut [4] -2
Half-Decent Proposal [12]
The Bart Wants What It Wants [10]
Tales from the Public Domain [9] +1
Weekend at Burnsie's [8]
I Am Furious (Yellow) [19]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [7]
Poppa's Got a Brand New Badge [14]

[Financial Panther]

Treehouse of Horror XII [14]
Jaws Wired Shut [4]
Half-Decent Proposal [12]
The Bart Wants What It Wants [10]
Tales from the Public Domain [10] +1
Weekend at Burnsie's [8]
I Am Furious (Yellow) [19]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [7]
Poppa's Got a Brand New Badge [12] -2

[The Spruce Moose]

Treehouse of Horror XII [14]
Jaws Wired Shut [4]
Half-Decent Proposal [12]
The Bart Wants What It Wants [11] +1
Tales from the Public Domain [10]
Weekend at Burnsie's [8]
I Am Furious (Yellow) [19]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [5] -2
Poppa's Got a Brand New Badge [12]

[The Spruce Moose]

Final List:

22. Gump Roast
21. The Frying Game
20. The Parent Rap
19. She of Little Faith
18. The Lastest Gun in the West
17. The Sweetest Apu
16. Sweets and Sour Marge
15. Brawl in the Family
14. Blame It On Lisa
13. Homer the Moe
12. A Hunka Hunka Burns in Love
11. The Old Man and the Key
10. The Blunder Years

[The Angry Animated Comedy Nerd]

Treehouse of Horror XII [12] -2
Jaws Wired Shut [4]
Half-Decent Proposal [12]
The Bart Wants What It Wants [11]
Tales from the Public Domain [10]
Weekend at Burnsie's [9] +1
I Am Furious (Yellow) [19]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [5]
Poppa's Got a Brand New Badge [12]

[Alex_Of_Darkness]

RIP The Blunder year

Treehouse of Horror XII [12] -2
Jaws Wired Shut [4]
Half-Decent Proposal [12]
The Bart Wants What It Wants [11]
Tales from the Public Domain [10]
Weekend at Burnsie's [7] -2
I Am Furious (Yellow) [19]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [6] +1
Poppa's Got a Brand New Badge [12]

[Zombies Rise from the Sea]

Treehouse of Horror XII [12]
Jaws Wired Shut [2] -2
Half-Decent Proposal [12]
The Bart Wants What It Wants [11]
Tales from the Public Domain [10]
Weekend at Burnsie's [7]
I Am Furious (Yellow) [20] +1
Little Girl in the Big Ten [6]
Poppa's Got a Brand New Badge [12]