The Simpsons Hurt and Heal Tournament: Season 13

[Safety Inspector]

Treehouse of Horror XII [10]
The Parent Rap [3]
Homer the Moe [10]
A Hunka Hunka Burns in Love [11]
The Blunder Years [11]
She of Little Faith [4]
Brawl in the Family [10]
Sweets and Sour Marge [8]
Jaws Wired Shut [10]
Half-Decent Proposal [13]
The Bart Wants What It Wants [11]
The Lastest Gun in the West [4]
The Old Man and the Key [11]
Tales from the Public Domain [11]
Blame It on Lisa [10]
Weekend at Burnsie's [11]
I Am Furious (Yellow) [13]
The Sweetest Apu [8]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [8] -2
The Frying Game [5]
Poppa's Got a Brand New Badge [15] +1

[Toomanygrandmas]

Treehouse of Horror XII [10]
The Parent Rap [3]
Homer the Moe [10]
A Hunka Hunka Burns in Love [11]
The Blunder Years [11]
She of Little Faith [4]
Brawl in the Family [10]
Sweets and Sour Marge [8]
Jaws Wired Shut [11] + 1
Half-Decent Proposal [13]
The Bart Wants What It Wants [11]
The Lastest Gun in the West [4]
The Old Man and the Key [11]
Tales from the Public Domain [11]
Blame It on Lisa [10]
Weekend at Burnsie's [11]
I Am Furious (Yellow) [13]
The Sweetest Apu [8]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [8]
The Frying Game [3] - 2
Poppa's Got a Brand New Badge [15]

Half-Decent, I am Furious Yellow, Jaws Wired Shut and The Old Man and the Key (or LGITBT) for the last four.

[The Governor]

The Lastest Gun in the West (D-)
The Parent Rap (F)
The Blunder Years (F)
Gump Roast (F)

^^^The 4 worst episodes of the season.

[leprechaun_dan]

Why did you give Blunder Years an F?

[Bartesque]

Spielbergo's votes were ignored, this is the list:

Treehouse of Horror XII [10]
The Parent Rap [3]
Homer the Moe [10]
A Hunka Hunka Burns in Love [11]
The Blunder Years [11]
She of Little Faith [4]
Brawl in the Family [10]
Sweets and Sour Marge [8]
Jaws Wired Shut [11]
Half-Decent Proposal [13]
The Bart Wants What It Wants [11]
The Lastest Gun in the West [4]
The Old Man and the Key [11]
Tales from the Public Domain [11]
Blame It on Lisa [10]
Weekend at Burnsie's [11]
I Am Furious (Yellow) [14]
The Sweetest Apu [8]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [6]
The Frying Game [3]
Poppa's Got a Brand New Badge [15]

[The Spruce Moose]

Final List:

22. Gump Roast

[Blobulle]

Treehouse of Horror XII [10]
The Parent Rap [1] -2
Homer the Moe [10]
A Hunka Hunka Burns in Love [11]
The Blunder Years [11]
She of Little Faith [4]
Brawl in the Family [10]
Sweets and Sour Marge [8]
Jaws Wired Shut [11]
Half-Decent Proposal [13]
The Bart Wants What It Wants [11]
The Lastest Gun in the West [4]
The Old Man and the Key [11]
Tales from the Public Domain [11]
Blame It on Lisa [10]
Weekend at Burnsie's [11]
I Am Furious (Yellow) [14]
The Sweetest Apu [8]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [7] +1
The Frying Game [3]
Poppa's Got a Brand New Badge [15]

[Oh, that's raspberry!]

Treehouse of Horror XII [10]
The Parent Rap [1]
Homer the Moe [10]
A Hunka Hunka Burns in Love [11]
The Blunder Years [11]
She of Little Faith [4]
Brawl in the Family [10]
Sweets and Sour Marge [8]
Jaws Wired Shut [11]
Half-Decent Proposal [13]
The Bart Wants What It Wants [11]
The Lastest Gun in the West [4]
The Old Man and the Key [11]
Tales from the Public Domain [11]
Blame It on Lisa [10]
Weekend at Burnsie's [11]
I Am Furious (Yellow) [15] +1
The Sweetest Apu [6] -2
Little Girl in the Big Ten [7]
The Frying Game [3]
Poppa's Got a Brand New Badge [15]

[The Spruce Moose]

Treehouse of Horror XII [10]
The Parent Rap [1]
Homer the Moe [10]
A Hunka Hunka Burns in Love [11]
The Blunder Years [11]
She of Little Faith [4]
Brawl in the Family [10]
Sweets and Sour Marge [8]
Jaws Wired Shut [11]
Half-Decent Proposal [13]
The Bart Wants What It Wants [12] +1
The Lastest Gun in the West [4]
The Old Man and the Key [11]
Tales from the Public Domain [11]
Blame It on Lisa [10]
Weekend at Burnsie's [11]
I Am Furious (Yellow) [15]
The Sweetest Apu [6]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [7]
The Frying Game [1] -2
Poppa's Got a Brand New Badge [15]

[Oh, that's raspberry!]

I don't care what ya'll say The Frying Game is better than all the Scully episodes from this season at least...

[cloneasaurus]

Treehouse of Horror XII [10]
The Parent Rap [1]
Homer the Moe [10]
A Hunka Hunka Burns in Love [11]
The Blunder Years [11]
She of Little Faith [4]
Brawl in the Family [10]
Sweets and Sour Marge [8]
Jaws Wired Shut [11]
Half-Decent Proposal [13]
The Bart Wants What It Wants [12]
The Lastest Gun in the West [4]
The Old Man and the Key [11]
Tales from the Public Domain [11]
Blame It on Lisa [10]
Weekend at Burnsie's [11]
I Am Furious (Yellow) [15]
The Sweetest Apu [6]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [8] +1
The Frying Game [-1] -2
Poppa's Got a Brand New Badge [15]

[mjb1124]

Treehouse of Horror XII [10]
The Parent Rap [1]
Homer the Moe [10]
A Hunka Hunka Burns in Love [11]
The Blunder Years [11]
She of Little Faith [4]
Brawl in the Family [10]
Sweets and Sour Marge [8]
Jaws Wired Shut [11]
Half-Decent Proposal [13]
The Bart Wants What It Wants [12]
The Lastest Gun in the West [4]
The Old Man and the Key [11]
Tales from the Public Domain [11]
Blame It on Lisa [10]
Weekend at Burnsie's [11]
I Am Furious (Yellow) [15]
The Sweetest Apu [4] -2
Little Girl in the Big Ten [9] +1
Poppa's Got a Brand New Badge [15]

[zartok-35]

Treehouse of Horror XII [10]
The Parent Rap [1]
Homer the Moe [10]
A Hunka Hunka Burns in Love [11]
The Blunder Years [11]
She of Little Faith [4]
Brawl in the Family [10]
Sweets and Sour Marge [6]-2
Jaws Wired Shut [11]
Half-Decent Proposal [13]
The Bart Wants What It Wants [12]
The Lastest Gun in the West [4]
The Old Man and the Key [11]
Tales from the Public Domain [11]
Blame It on Lisa [10]
Weekend at Burnsie's [11]
I Am Furious (Yellow) [15]
The Sweetest Apu [4]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [10]+1
Poppa's Got a Brand New Badge [15]

[Bartesque]

Treehouse of Horror XII [10]
The Parent Rap [1]
Homer the Moe [10]
A Hunka Hunka Burns in Love [11]
The Blunder Years [11]
She of Little Faith [4]
Brawl in the Family [10]
Sweets and Sour Marge [6]
Jaws Wired Shut [11]
Half-Decent Proposal [13]
The Bart Wants What It Wants [12]
The Lastest Gun in the West [4]
The Old Man and the Key [11]
Tales from the Public Domain [11]
Blame It on Lisa [10]
Weekend at Burnsie's [11]
I Am Furious (Yellow) [16] +1
The Sweetest Apu [4]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [8] -2
Poppa's Got a Brand New Badge [15]

[Nauru-1]

The Frying Game at least has some moments that feel genuine unlike the Parent Rap.

Treehouse of Horror XII [10]
The Parent Rap [-1] -2
Homer the Moe [10]
A Hunka Hunka Burns in Love [11]
The Blunder Years [11]
She of Little Faith [4]
Brawl in the Family [10]
Sweets and Sour Marge [6]
Jaws Wired Shut [11]
Half-Decent Proposal [13]
The Bart Wants What It Wants [12]
The Lastest Gun in the West [4]
The Old Man and the Key [11]
Tales from the Public Domain [11]
Blame It on Lisa [10]
Weekend at Burnsie's [11]
I Am Furious (Yellow) [16]
The Sweetest Apu [4]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [9] +1
Poppa's Got a Brand New Badge [15]

[The Governor]

Why did you give Blunder Years an F?

Homer's screaming montage, the "Stand by Me" ripoff wasn't funny, Smither's origin story was lame, the camera angles changing when it was supposed to be a single camera, etc. This was about as funny as someone as listening to someone dragging their nails over a blackboard over a loudspeaker and it couldn't even be funny in the "it's so bad it's good" kind of way.

[zach]

The Parent Rap out waaaaaayyyyyy too early.

Treehouse of Horror XII [10]
Homer the Moe [10]
A Hunka Hunka Burns in Love [12] +1
The Blunder Years [11]
She of Little Faith [2] -2
Brawl in the Family [10]
Sweets and Sour Marge [6]
Jaws Wired Shut [11]
Half-Decent Proposal [13]
The Bart Wants What It Wants [12]
The Lastest Gun in the West [4]
The Old Man and the Key [11]
Tales from the Public Domain [11]
Blame It on Lisa [10]
Weekend at Burnsie's [11]
I Am Furious (Yellow) [16]
The Sweetest Apu [4]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [9]
Poppa's Got a Brand New Badge [15]

[Brad Lascelle]

The Parent Rap out waaaaaayyyyyy too early.

The Parent Rap introduced the unpleasantness of Judge Constance Harm as a recurring character.
It had to die early as penance.

[The Spruce Moose]

Final List:

22. Gump Roast
21. The Frying Game
20. The Parent Rap

A Hunka Hunka Burns in Love and Little Girl in the Big Ten next please

[zach]

A Hunka Hunka Burns in Love next please

over my dead body.

[MagicalManFromHappyLand]

Treehouse of Horror XII [10]
Homer the Moe [10]
A Hunka Hunka Burns in Love [12]
The Blunder Years [11]
She of Little Faith [2]
Brawl in the Family [10]
Sweets and Sour Marge [6]
Jaws Wired Shut [11]
Half-Decent Proposal [13]
The Bart Wants What It Wants [12]
The Lastest Gun in the West [2] -2
The Old Man and the Key [11]
Tales from the Public Domain [11]
Blame It on Lisa [10]
Weekend at Burnsie's [11]
I Am Furious (Yellow) [16]
The Sweetest Apu [4]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [9]
Poppa's Got a Brand New Badge [16] +1

[Handsome B. Wonderful]

the camera angles changing when it was supposed to be a single camera,

Careful there, Jake, you're starting to sound like Julie.

[The Governor]

If I was Julie, I'd be praising the angles...the beautiful, beautiful angles.

[Financial Panther]

Treehouse of Horror XII [10]
Homer the Moe [10]
A Hunka Hunka Burns in Love [12]
The Blunder Years [11]
She of Little Faith [0] -2
Brawl in the Family [10]
Sweets and Sour Marge [6]
Jaws Wired Shut [11]
Half-Decent Proposal [13]
The Bart Wants What It Wants [12]
The Lastest Gun in the West [2]
The Old Man and the Key [11]
Tales from the Public Domain [12] +1
Blame It on Lisa [10]
Weekend at Burnsie's [11]
I Am Furious (Yellow) [16]
The Sweetest Apu [4]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [9]
Poppa's Got a Brand New Badge [16]

[Lionel Hutz]

Treehouse of Horror XII [10]
Homer the Moe [10]
A Hunka Hunka Burns in Love [12]
The Blunder Years [11]
Brawl in the Family [10]
Sweets and Sour Marge [4] -2
Jaws Wired Shut [11]
Half-Decent Proposal [13]
The Bart Wants What It Wants [12]
The Lastest Gun in the West [2]
The Old Man and the Key [11]
Tales from the Public Domain [12]
Blame It on Lisa [10]
Weekend at Burnsie's [11]
I Am Furious (Yellow) [16]
The Sweetest Apu [4]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [9]
Poppa's Got a Brand New Badge [17] +1

[The Spruce Moose]

Final List:

22. Gump Roast
21. The Frying Game
20. The Parent Rap
19. She of Little Faith

[The Angry Animated Comedy Nerd]

Treehouse of Horror XII [10]
Homer the Moe [10]
A Hunka Hunka Burns in Love [12]
The Blunder Years [11]
Brawl in the Family [10]
Sweets and Sour Marge [4]
Jaws Wired Shut [11]
Half-Decent Proposal [13]
The Bart Wants What It Wants [10] -2
The Lastest Gun in the West [2]
The Old Man and the Key [11]
Tales from the Public Domain [12]
Blame It on Lisa [10]
Weekend at Burnsie's [12] +1
I Am Furious (Yellow) [16]
The Sweetest Apu [4]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [9]
Poppa's Got a Brand New Badge [17]

[Prune Tracy]

She of Little Faith and Gump Roast both out far too early.

Treehouse of Horror XII [10]
Homer the Moe [10]
A Hunka Hunka Burns in Love [12]
The Blunder Years [9] -2
Brawl in the Family [10]
Sweets and Sour Marge [4]
Jaws Wired Shut [12] +1
Half-Decent Proposal [13]
The Bart Wants What It Wants [10]
The Lastest Gun in the West [2]
The Old Man and the Key [11]
Tales from the Public Domain [12]
Blame It on Lisa [10]
Weekend at Burnsie's [12]
I Am Furious (Yellow) [16]
The Sweetest Apu [4]
Little Girl in the Big Ten [9]
Poppa's Got a Brand New Badge [17]