The Simpsons Hurt and Heal Tournament: Season 10

[zach]

16 and 20 are superior to 11 and 12 as well

uhhh

[Oh, that's raspberry!]

If you aren't aware by now you probably haven't been paying much attention to my posts, but I consider Season 16 to be the best post-classic season other than 9. 20 has some poor episodes, but nothing of Jockey Elves or Africa or Tennis level terrible, imo...

[Alex_Of_Darkness]

We should do all the seasons

[ANdre1001]

16 and 20 are superior to 11 and 12 as well...hell more seasons from the Jean Era are too probably. If you want to stop at 16 and then make four semifinal brackets I guess I could get behind that simply due to lack of interest making the later season threads take forever, but I'd still much prefer going through 22 at least...

It's pretty reasonable if you want to continue all the way, but Im pretty sure from now on a lot of people will loose interest in the games including myself, stoping in season 16 sounds reasonable since it gives more options.

[Oh, that's raspberry!]

Well I mean I'm not the one making all these threads and I'm not the one that makes the decisions or anything. If I had things my way we'd go through Season 22, but I'd be willing to still participate even if the popular opinion was to stop after Season 16. Really it's up to everyone...

[Alex_Of_Darkness]

Me, I'm totally agree with Oh, That's raspberry!

[zach]

If you aren't aware by now you probably haven't been paying much attention to my posts, but I consider Season 16 to be the best post-classic season other than 9. 20 has some poor episodes, but nothing of Jockey Elves or Africa or Tennis level terrible, imo...

i was just messing.

[TheOttoThe]

This is a terrible list with a horribly overrated episode in second place. Here's hopin' Wild Barts OR Lisa Gets an A will win.

Mayored to the Mob stayed on because of its comedic moments, not the writing. Personally I thought it was hilarious, especially the line

"Il be fine, Bart go start Daddy's car"

Also, Mark Hamils guest role was pleasant as always

[Handsome B. Wonderful]

What about your sprained ankle?

Oh, yeah, see about that... ZZZZZFFFFT *runs away*

Still really satisfied with the way this list turned out.

[Brad Lascelle]

16 and 20 are superior to 11 and 12 as well...hell more seasons from the Jean Era are too probably. If you want to stop at 16 and then make four semifinal brackets I guess I could get behind that simply due to lack of interest making the later season threads take forever, but I'd still much prefer going through 22 at least...

We can even take a crack at Season 23 as it'll be over by the time it comes up in the rotation.

You can't just choose an arbitrary spot to stop running polls based on a speculative "assumption" that people will lose interest in them.
Especially because you'll never be able to get people to agree on what said ideal "stop point" should be.

I personally consider every season from 9 through 23 to be on a level playing field due to overall inconsistency... some more inconsistent than others. But all have their highlight episodes.

[Safety Inspector]

My forecast for Season 11 Top4:

1.E-I-E-I-(Annoyed Grunt)
2.Guess Who's Coming to Criticize Dinner?
3.Last Tap Dance is Springfield

I don't sure for #4, and my forecast for #4:

Treehouse of Horror X- 60%
Pygmoelian- 25%
Missonary Impossible- 15%

Behind the Laughter has too many haters.

[Financial Panther]

And we all know what happens to divisive episodes!

[The Spruce Moose]

I think i've made it abundantly clear on this forum what I think of the post-Season 10 seasons but I still want to continue. If only for the satisfaction of seeing Trilogy of Error or Eternal Moonshine roundly trounced by he actually excellent episdoes

[The Spruce Moose]

Final list:

23. Monty Can't Buy Me Love
22. Homer Simpson in: "Kidney Trouble"
21. Homer to the Max
20. Sunday, Cruddy Sunday
19. Make Room for Lisa
18. When You Dish Upon A Star
17. Viva Ned Flanders
16. Maximum Homerdrive
15. Marge Simpson in: Screaming Yellow Honkers
14. D'oh-in in the Wind
13. I'm with Cupid
12. Thirty Minutes Over Tokyo
11. They Saved Lisa's Brain
10. The Old Man and the 'C' Student
9. Simpsons Bible Stories
8. Lard of the Dance
7. The Wizard of Evergreen Terrace
6. Bart the Mother
5. Mom and Pop Art
4. Treehouse of Horror IX
3. Lisa Gets an 'A'
1= Mayored to the Mob
1= Wild Barts Can't Be Broken

[Toomanygrandmas]

Glad to see that Lisa Gets an A and Mayored to the Mob got through, though it's a shame that the other two I'd have liked to have made it through, just missed out (well not really, they were in single figures, the others were in the twenties).

[Alex_Of_Darkness]

Good choice for the future of the hurt and heal "The spruce moose"

[leprechaun_dan]

Good winner, but I feel bad for being away in order to help save Simpsons Bible Stories and I'm with Cupid. But deserving winner, nonetheless.

[Company Picnic]

Why not just increase the points on the downvote from 2 to 4 after Season 16?

That way it'll be over quicker and needs less participation

[Financial Panther]

I don't understand why people want this to end quickly. The post-classic seasons will be just as fun as the classic ones!