The Simpsons Hurt and Heal Tournament: Season 9

[leprechaun_dan]

RIP Bart Carny. Although you're not that good.

The City of New York vs. Homer Simpson [15] +1
Lisa's Sax [14]
Treehouse of Horror VIII [11]
The Cartridge Family [11]
Lisa the Skeptic [8]
Realty Bites [11]
Miracle on Evergreen Terrace [8]
The Joy of Sect [10]
Das Bus [14]
Dumbbell Indemnity [8]
Lisa the Simpson [10]
This Little Wiggy [8]
Simpson Tide [9]
The Trouble with Trillions [3] -2
Girly Edition [13]
Trash of the Titans [2]
King of the Hill [11]
Lost Our Lisa [11]
Natural Born Kissers [9]

I have a question for this game. If one of the episodes has one point remaining, and you want to eliminate two points from it, does that mean we can use the other point to take away a point for another episode?

...point... point... point...

[Zombies Rise from the Sea]

The City of New York vs. Homer Simpson [15]
Lisa's Sax [14]
Treehouse of Horror VIII [11]
The Cartridge Family [11]
Lisa the Skeptic [8]
Realty Bites [11]
Miracle on Evergreen Terrace [8]
The Joy of Sect [10]
Das Bus [14]
Dumbbell Indemnity [8]
Lisa the Simpson [10]
This Little Wiggy [9] +1
Simpson Tide [9]
The Trouble with Trillions [3]
Girly Edition [13]
Trash of the Titans [0] -2
King of the Hill [11]
Lost Our Lisa [11]
Natural Born Kissers [9]

[The Spruce Moose]

Final List:
25. All Singing, All Dancing
24. The Principal and the Pauper
23. The Two Mrs Nahasapeemapetilons
22. Bart Star
21. Bart Carny
20. Trash of the Titans (thanks leprechaun_dan)

[leprechaun_dan]

^Add Trash of the Titans to the list.

[TheOttoThe]

Reality Bites got my vote on the merit that its the last episode to feature Lionel Hutz

[The Spruce Moose]

The City of New York vs. Homer Simpson [15]
Lisa's Sax [14]
Treehouse of Horror VIII [11]
The Cartridge Family [11]
Lisa the Skeptic [8]
Realty Bites [11]
Miracle on Evergreen Terrace [8]
The Joy of Sect [11] +1
Das Bus [14]
Dumbbell Indemnity [8]
Lisa the Simpson [10]
This Little Wiggy [7] -2
Simpson Tide [9]
The Trouble with Trillions [3]
Girly Edition [13]
King of the Hill [11]
Lost Our Lisa [11]
Natural Born Kissers [9]

[HMS pinafore]

The City of New York vs. Homer Simpson [15]
Lisa's Sax [14]
Treehouse of Horror VIII [11]
The Cartridge Family [12]+1
Lisa the Skeptic [8]
Realty Bites [11]
Miracle on Evergreen Terrace [8]
The Joy of Sect [11]
Das Bus [14]
Dumbbell Indemnity [8]
Lisa the Simpson [10]
This Little Wiggy [7]
Simpson Tide [9]
The Trouble with Trillions [3]
Girly Edition [11]-2
King of the Hill [11]
Lost Our Lisa [11]
Natural Born Kissers [9]

[Oh, that's raspberry!]

The City of New York vs. Homer Simpson [13] -2
Lisa's Sax [15] +1
Treehouse of Horror VIII [11]
The Cartridge Family [12]
Lisa the Skeptic [8]
Realty Bites [11]
Miracle on Evergreen Terrace [8]
The Joy of Sect [11]
Das Bus [14]
Dumbbell Indemnity [8]
Lisa the Simpson [10]
This Little Wiggy [7]
Simpson Tide [9]
The Trouble with Trillions [3]
Girly Edition [11]
King of the Hill [11]
Lost Our Lisa [11]
Natural Born Kissers [9]

Voting down episodes for this season has already become rather difficult for me as I consider them all to be of similar quality. Aside from Lisa's Sax, which I think is easily the best episode of this season, I really wouldn't mind seeing ANY of the remaining episodes joining it for the top 4...except perhaps for New York which while enjoyable seems overrated to me.

[Christopher the Chef]

The City of New York vs. Homer Simpson [13]
Lisa's Sax [15]
Treehouse of Horror VIII [11]
The Cartridge Family [10] -2
Lisa the Skeptic [8]
Realty Bites [11]
Miracle on Evergreen Terrace [8]
The Joy of Sect [11]
Das Bus [14]
Dumbbell Indemnity [8]
Lisa the Simpson [10]
This Little Wiggy [7]
Simpson Tide [10] +1
The Trouble with Trillions [3]
Girly Edition [11]
King of the Hill [11]
Lost Our Lisa [11]
Natural Born Kissers [9]

[Blobulle]

The City of New York vs. Homer Simpson [13]
Lisa's Sax [15]
Treehouse of Horror VIII [11]
The Cartridge Family [10]
Lisa the Skeptic [8]
Realty Bites [11]
Miracle on Evergreen Terrace [6] -2
The Joy of Sect [11]
Das Bus [14]
Dumbbell Indemnity [8]
Lisa the Simpson [10]
This Little Wiggy [7]
Simpson Tide [10]
The Trouble with Trillions [3]
Girly Edition [11]
King of the Hill [11]
Lost Our Lisa [12] +1
Natural Born Kissers [9]

[Safety Inspector]

The City of New York vs. Homer Simpson [14] +1
Lisa's Sax [15]
Treehouse of Horror VIII [11]
The Cartridge Family [8] -2 (DIE!)
Lisa the Skeptic [8]
Realty Bites [11]
Miracle on Evergreen Terrace [6]
The Joy of Sect [11]
Das Bus [14]
Dumbbell Indemnity [8]
Lisa the Simpson [10]
This Little Wiggy [7]
Simpson Tide [10]
The Trouble with Trillions [3]
Girly Edition [11]
King of the Hill [11]
Lost Our Lisa [12]
Natural Born Kissers [9]

[Company Picnic]

The City of New York vs. Homer Simpson [14]
Lisa's Sax [15]
Treehouse of Horror VIII [11]
The Cartridge Family [8]
Lisa the Skeptic [8]
Realty Bites [11]
Miracle on Evergreen Terrace [6]
The Joy of Sect [11]
Das Bus [14]
Dumbbell Indemnity [8]
Lisa the Simpson [10]
This Little Wiggy [8] +1
Simpson Tide [10]
The Trouble with Trillions [3]
Girly Edition [11]
King of the Hill [9] -2
Lost Our Lisa [12]
Natural Born Kissers [9]

[mjb1124]

The City of New York vs. Homer Simpson [14]
Lisa's Sax [15]
Treehouse of Horror VIII [11]
The Cartridge Family [8]
Lisa the Skeptic [8]
Realty Bites [11]
Miracle on Evergreen Terrace [6]
The Joy of Sect [11]
Das Bus [14]
Dumbbell Indemnity [8]
Lisa the Simpson [11] +1
This Little Wiggy [8]
Simpson Tide [10]
The Trouble with Trillions [1] -2
Girly Edition [11]
King of the Hill [9]
Lost Our Lisa [12]
Natural Born Kissers [9]

[Léo Pard]

RIP Trash of the Titans and Bart Star.

The City of New York vs. Homer Simpson [14]
Lisa's Sax [15]
Treehouse of Horror VIII [11]
The Cartridge Family [8]
Lisa the Skeptic [8]
Realty Bites [11]
Miracle on Evergreen Terrace [6]
The Joy of Sect [11]
Das Bus [14]
Dumbbell Indemnity [8]
Lisa the Simpson [11]
This Little Wiggy [8]
Simpson Tide [10]
The Trouble with Trillions [2] +1
Girly Edition [11]
King of the Hill [9]
Lost Our Lisa [12]
Natural Born Kissers [7] -2

[Bartesque]

The City of New York vs. Homer Simpson [14]
Lisa's Sax [15]
Treehouse of Horror VIII [11]
The Cartridge Family [9] +1
Lisa the Skeptic [8]
Realty Bites [11]
Miracle on Evergreen Terrace [6]
The Joy of Sect [11]
Das Bus [14]
Dumbbell Indemnity [8]
Lisa the Simpson [9] -2
This Little Wiggy [8]
Simpson Tide [10]
The Trouble with Trillions [2]
Girly Edition [11]
King of the Hill [9]
Lost Our Lisa [12]
Natural Born Kissers [7]

[Brad Lascelle]

Trouble With Trillions, you're under arrest, for grand, grand, grand, grand stupidity.

The City of New York vs. Homer Simpson [14]
Lisa's Sax [15]
Treehouse of Horror VIII [11]
The Cartridge Family [9]
Lisa the Skeptic [8]
Realty Bites [11]
Miracle on Evergreen Terrace [6]
The Joy of Sect [11]
Das Bus [15] +1
Dumbbell Indemnity [8]
Lisa the Simpson [9]
This Little Wiggy [8]
Simpson Tide [10]
The Trouble with Trillions [0]
Girly Edition [11]
King of the Hill [9]
Lost Our Lisa [12]
Natural Born Kissers [7]

[Homer Defined]

The City of New York vs. Homer Simpson [14]
Lisa's Sax [15]
Treehouse of Horror VIII [11]
The Cartridge Family [10]+1
Lisa the Skeptic [8]
Realty Bites [11]
Miracle on Evergreen Terrace [6]
The Joy of Sect [11]
Das Bus [15]
Dumbbell Indemnity [8]
Lisa the Simpson [9]
This Little Wiggy [8]
Simpson Tide [10]
Girly Edition [11]
King of the Hill [7]-2
Lost Our Lisa [12]
Natural Born Kissers [7]

[Company Picnic]

Time to get rid of King of the Hill. Seriously, apart from a few decent jokes, it feels like it could be in Seasons 11 or 12 to me.

[zach]

my 3 favourite episodes are gone.

[Financial Panther]

Time to get rid of King of the Hill. Seriously, apart from a few decent jokes, it feels like it could be in Seasons 11 or 12 to me.

Whaaaaat?? No way! This is among the most underrated episodes of the show.

[King-Size Homer]

The City of New York vs. Homer Simpson [14]
Lisa's Sax [15]
Treehouse of Horror VIII [11]
The Cartridge Family [11] + 1
Lisa the Skeptic [8]
Realty Bites [11]
Miracle on Evergreen Terrace [6]
The Joy of Sect [11]
Das Bus [15]
Dumbbell Indemnity [8]
Lisa the Simpson [9]
This Little Wiggy [8]
Simpson Tide [8] - 2
Girly Edition [11]
King of the Hill [7]
Lost Our Lisa [12]
Natural Born Kissers [7]

[Lionel Hutz]

Simpson Tide [8] - 2

Bastard! he's always one step ahead

[Prune Tracy]

Time to get rid of King of the Hill. Seriously, apart from a few decent jokes, it feels like it could be in Seasons 11 or 12 to me.

I'll pretend I didn't read this.

Also, happy to see that This Episode is Absolute Trash (of the Titans) is gone.

The City of New York vs. Homer Simpson [14]
Lisa's Sax [15]
Treehouse of Horror VIII [11]
The Cartridge Family [11]
Lisa the Skeptic [8]
Realty Bites [11]
Miracle on Evergreen Terrace [6]
The Joy of Sect [9] -2
Das Bus [15]
Dumbbell Indemnity [8]
Lisa the Simpson [9]
This Little Wiggy [8]
Simpson Tide [8]
Girly Edition [11]
King of the Hill [8] +1
Lost Our Lisa [12]
Natural Born Kissers [7]

[Financial Panther]

The City of New York vs. Homer Simpson [14]
Lisa's Sax [15]
Treehouse of Horror VIII [11]
The Cartridge Family [11]
Lisa the Skeptic [8]
Realty Bites [11]
Miracle on Evergreen Terrace [4] -2
The Joy of Sect [9]
Das Bus [15]
Dumbbell Indemnity [8]
Lisa the Simpson [9]
This Little Wiggy [8]
Simpson Tide [8]
Girly Edition [12] +1
King of the Hill [8]
Lost Our Lisa [12]
Natural Born Kissers [7]

[zach]

Also, happy to see that This Episode is Absolute Trash (of the Titans) is gone.

YOU TRASH EATING STINKBAGS!

[MagicalManFromHappyLand]

The City of New York vs. Homer Simpson [14]
Lisa's Sax [15]
Treehouse of Horror VIII [11]
The Cartridge Family [11]
Lisa the Skeptic [8]
Realty Bites [11]
Miracle on Evergreen Terrace [4]
The Joy of Sect [9]
Das Bus [15]
Dumbbell Indemnity [8]
Lisa the Simpson [10] +1
This Little Wiggy [8]
Simpson Tide [8]
Girly Edition [12]
King of the Hill [8]
Lost Our Lisa [10] -2
Natural Born Kissers [7]

[Alex_Of_Darkness]

The City of New York vs. Homer Simpson [14]
Lisa's Sax [15]
Treehouse of Horror VIII [11]
The Cartridge Family [12] +1
Lisa the Skeptic [8]
Realty Bites [11]
Miracle on Evergreen Terrace [4]
The Joy of Sect [9]
Das Bus [15]
Dumbbell Indemnity [8]
Lisa the Simpson [10]
This Little Wiggy [8]
Simpson Tide [8]
Girly Edition [10] -2
King of the Hill [8]
Lost Our Lisa [10]
Natural Born Kissers [7]

[AndeR53]

The City of New York vs. Homer Simpson [14]
Lisa's Sax [16] +1
Treehouse of Horror VIII [11]
The Cartridge Family [12]
Lisa the Skeptic [8]
Realty Bites [11]
Miracle on Evergreen Terrace [4]
The Joy of Sect [7] -2
Das Bus [15]
Dumbbell Indemnity [8]
Lisa the Simpson [10]
This Little Wiggy [8]
Simpson Tide [8]
Girly Edition [10]
King of the Hill [8]
Lost Our Lisa [10]
Natural Born Kissers [7]

[ANdre1001]

Am I wasting my votes in Natural Born Kissers?? I love that episode but I can't save it on my own

The City of New York vs. Homer Simpson [14]
Lisa's Sax [16] +1
Treehouse of Horror VIII [11]
The Cartridge Family [12]
Lisa the Skeptic [8]
Realty Bites [11]
Miracle on Evergreen Terrace [4]
The Joy of Sect [7]
Das Bus [15]
Dumbbell Indemnity [8]
Lisa the Simpson [10]
This Little Wiggy [8]
Simpson Tide [8]
Girly Edition [10]
King of the Hill [6] -2
Lost Our Lisa [10]
Natural Born Kissers [8] +1

[Lionel Hutz]

The City of New York vs. Homer Simpson [14]
Lisa's Sax [16] +1
Treehouse of Horror VIII [11]
The Cartridge Family [12]
Lisa the Skeptic [8]
Realty Bites [11]
Miracle on Evergreen Terrace [4]
The Joy of Sect [7]
Das Bus [15]
Dumbbell Indemnity [6] -2
Lisa the Simpson [10]
This Little Wiggy [8]
Simpson Tide [9] +1
Girly Edition [10]
King of the Hill [6]
Lost Our Lisa [10]
Natural Born Kissers [8]