The NHC Top 50 post-classic episodes

[Abe Simpson's gay lover]

This looks like fun. However you guys are so not organised! Should have done this throughout the month of April and you should set up a definitive date for closure.

[Alex_Of_Darkness]

25. Don't fear the roofer
24. The Fat And The Furriest
23. Diatribe of a Mad Housewife
22. Skinner's Sense of Snow
21. The Great Louse Detective
20. Simple Simpson
19. The Regina Monologues
18. THOH XIV
17. My Mother the Carjacker
16. Moe Baby Blues
15. The Wizard of Evergreen Terrace
14. Mayored to the Mob
13. Holidays of future passed
12. I, (Annoyed Grunt)-Bot
11. E-I-E-I-(Annoyed Grunt)
10. Wild Barts Can't Be Broken
9. The Seemingly Never-ending Story
8. Thirty Minutes Over Tokyo
7. Marge Gamer
6. HOMR
5. The Way We Weren't
4. The Blunder Years
3. Eternal moonshine of the Simpsons mind
2. Trilogy of Error
1. Maximum Homerdrive

[Old painty-can Ned]

Just have your lists in by the start of April.

[parklife]

from favourite to least favourite:

1. little big mom
2. the wizard of evergreen terrace
3. the computer wore menace shoes
4. saddlesore galactica
5. insane clown poppy
6. alone again, natura-diddly
7. maximum homerdrive
8. missionary impossible
9. pokey mom
10. skinner's sense of snow
11. the mansion family
12. behind the laughter
13. when you dish upon a star
14. treehouse of horror x
15. take my wife, sleaze
16. last tap dance in springfield
17. homer simpson in: 'kidney trouble'
18. mom and pop art
19. wild barts can't be broken
20. homer to the max
21. children of a lesser clod
22. monty can't buy me love
23. treehouse of horror xi
24. worst episode ever
25. homer the moe

[Brad Lascelle]

It's going to be interesting when we have the results and see an episode like Saddlesore Galactica appear on both the Bottom 50 episode AND the Top 50 Post-Classic era episode lists. How does that make sense?

[parklife]

in regards to saddlesore galactica specifically - i'm sure it's only been on like two lists so far, and i'd say most people here seem to hate it enough to not include it so i don't really think it actually has a chance of making the top cumulative list. same goes for the collectively hated episodes from season eleven [that i like].

don't worry

[Handsome B. Wonderful]

Well it's still better than 70% of other post-classic episodes.

[Gladys the Groovy Mule]

never known what's wrong with Saddlesore or KTAAR. Both cromulent (for that era anyway) 6/10's for me

[Oh, that's raspberry!]

It only makes sense because different people are giving the lists...

[zach]

It's going to be interesting when we have the results and see an episode like Saddlesore Galactica appear on both the Bottom 50 episode AND the Top 50 Post-Classic era episode lists. How does that make sense?

yeah i'm pretty sure it's only gonna be on mine, melody's and financial panther's list.

[Handsome B. Wonderful]

I seriously pulled this list out of my ass. I haven't seen a little more than half of post-classic episodes in years.

1. The Computer Wore Menace Shoes
2. The Great Money Caper
3. HOMЯ
4. Bart vs. Lisa vs. the Third Grade
5. No Loan Again, Naturally
6. Weekend at Burnsies
7. Treehouse of Horror IX
8. The Wizard of Evergreen Terrace
9. Guess Who's Coming to Criticize Dinner
10. Moe Baby Blues
11. Holidays of Future Passed
12. Trilogy of Error
13. Grift of the Magi
14. Hungry, Hungry Homer
15. Jaws Wired Shut
16. Wild Barts Can't Be Broken
17. The Parent Rap
18. The Great Louse Detective
19. Monty Can't Buy Me Love
20. C.E. D'oh
21. Saddlesore Galactica
22. I D'oh Bot
23. The President Wore Pearls
24. The Dad Who Knew Too Little
25. The Wandering Juvie

[Léo Pard]

Even if season 10 is part of Golden Age IMO, this is my approximative top 25 from seasons 10 to 22 :

25. Gone Maggie Gone
24. Treehouse of Horror IX
23. The Wizard of Evergreen Terrace
22. 24 Minutes
21. Eternal Moonshine of the Simpson Mind
20. Homer Simpson in : "Kidney Trouble"
19. The Fraudcast News
18. No Loan Again, Naturally
17. Treehouse of Horror XIV
16. My Mother the Carjacker
15. Papa's Got a Brand New Badge
14. Pygmoelian
13. Hungry Hungry Homer
12. The Fat and the Furriest
11. The Great Louse Detective
10. The Seemingly Never-Ending Story
9. E-I-E-I-D'oh
8. Lisa Gets an 'A'
7. Thirty Minutes Over Tokyo
6. Mayored to the Mob
5. Trilogy of Error
4. The Computer Wore Menace Shoes
3. The Mansion Family
2. Mom and Pop Art
1. Maximum Homerdrive

[King-Size Homer]

This list might not be completely accurate but here it is anyway. Also I've only seen a miniscule amount of episodes that are not on DVD, so I'm sure if I saw those this list would be a little different.

25. The Blunder Years
24. How the Test Was Won
23. Worst Episode Ever
22. Half Decent Proposal
21. ‘Scuse Me While I Miss the Sky
20. C.E.D’oh
19. Wild Barts Can’t Be Broken
18. Jaws Wired Shut
17. E-I-E-I D’oh
16. HOMR
15. Weekend at Burnsie’s
14. Skinner’s Sense of Snow
13. Holidays of Future Passed
12. Mayored to the Mob
11. The Mansion Family
10. Treehouse of Horror IX
9. Days of Wine and D’oh’ses
8. The Great Louse Detective
7. Moe Baby Blues
6. Trilogy of Error
5. Bart the Mother
4. Lisa Gets an A
3. Poppa’s Got a Brand New Badge
2. Hungry, Hungry Homer
1. The Wizard of Evergreen Terrace

[MagicalManFromHappyLand]

I'm quite pleased to see that KTAAR and Moe Goes From Rags to Riches haven't placed on a single list so far. I don't care about if Saddlesore Galactica is getting votes, I don't take it very seriously because I don't think the writers intended it to be took seriously.

[leprechaun_dan]

This was actually more difficult than I'd thought but here's my 100% legitimate list.

25. The Wandering Juvie
24. Wild Barts Can't Be Broken
23. Skinner's Sense of Snow
22. How I Wet Your Mother
21. Gone Maggie Gone
20. The Bob Next Door
19. Thank God, It's Doomsday
18. Grift of the Magi
17. Little Girl in the Big Ten
16. 500 Keys
15. Girls Just Want to Have Sums
14. Treehouse of Horror IX
13. 24 Minutes
12. O Brother, Where Bart Thou?
11. I'm Spelling As Fast As I Can
10. The Way We Weren't
9. Simple Simpson
8. The Haw-Hawed Couple
7. Don't Fear the Roofer
6. I Am Furious Yellow
5. The Book Job
4. Eternal Moonshine of the Simpson Mind
3. The Debarted
2. Holidays of Future Passed
1. Trilogy of Error

Simpsons Bible Stories would be my 26

[The Spruce Moose]

cannot be fucked doing a re-watch for this so here's my list:

25. New Kids on the Blecch
24. Diatribe of a Mad Housewife
23. The Monkey Suit
22. Old Yeller Belly
21. Lisa the Tree Hugger
20. When You Dish Upon A Star
19. Homer to the Max
18. Last Tap Dance in Springfield
17. The Bart of War
16. Fraudcast News
15. My Fair Laddy
14. The Bart Wants What It Wants
13. The Dad Who Knew Too Little
12. Fat Man and Little Boy
11. Simple Simpson
10. Lard of the Dance
9. Thirty Minutes Over Tokyo
8. The President Wore Pearls
7. Behind the Laughter
6. D'oh-in in the Wind
5. Mr. Spritz Goes to Washington
4. Mom and Pop Art
3. Mayored to the Mob
2. They Saved Lisa's Brain
1. Hungry, Hungry Homer

[CollectorCharlie]

Great idea. Will post a list eventually.

[Mr Black]

new kids on the bleech? holy cow I've seen it all...

[Oh, that's raspberry!]

Surprised me too, but then I suppose the rather large potential for varying responses is part of what makes doing something like this so interesting...

[Prune Tracy]

I actually thought New Kids on the Blecch was a pretty good episode. If I were to make a list, it might show up. The only thing that drags it down is the stupid ending.

EDIT: And speaking of "If I were to make a list", here it is. (And lo and behold, Blecch did make it.)

25. The Heartbroke Kid
24. She of Little Faith
23. Mom and Pop Art
22. Goo Goo Gai Pan
21. Simple Simpson
20. Guess Who’s Coming to Criticize Dinner?
19. Grift of the Magi
18. New Kids on the Blecch
17. Fraudcast News
16. Trilogy of Error
15. Jaws Wired Shut
14. Hello Gutter, Hello Fadder
13. The Old Man and the ‘C’ Student
12. Homer to the Max
11. Bart the Mother
10. They Saved Lisa’s Brain
9. Wild Barts Can’t Be Broken
8. I Am Furious (Yellow)
7. 24 Minutes
6. Treehouse of Horror IX
5. The Way We Weren’t
4. Lard of the Dance
3. The Wizard of Evergreen Terrace
2. Moe Baby Blues
1. Eeny Teeny Maya Moe

[CollectorCharlie]

These are the episodes that got an A from me:

25) Alone Again, Natura-Diddly
24) My Mother the Carjacker
23) Jaws Wired Shut
22) I'm Goin' to Praiseland
21) Eternal Moonshine of the Simpson Mind (I recall really liking it but not over the moon for it)
20) Thank God It's Doomsday
19) Postcards from the Wedge
18) Springfield Up
17) Pray Anything
16) Little Orphan Millie
15) The Blue and The Grey
14) The Strong Arms of the Ma
13) On a Clear Day I Can't See My Sister
12) Ice Cream of Margie With the Light Blue Hair
11) Eeny Teeny Maya Moe
10) Trilogy Of Error
9) Marge Simpson in: "Screaming Yellow Honkers" (good psychological Marge ep)
8) Lisa Gets an A (good Lisa plot. lobster sub plot was even better)
7) Bart to the Future
6) Holidays Of Future Passed (best comic consistency in a while)
5) Eight Misbehavin'
4) Marge Gamer (Barts online persona sealed the deal lol)
3) Don't Fear the Roofer
2) The Blunder Years
1) The Wizard of Evergreen Terrace

Runners up that also got A's in no particular order:

Homer Scissorhands
How Munched Is That Birdie in the Window
Today, I Am a Clown
The Great Money Caper
Regarding Margie
The Ziff Who Came to Dinner
E-I-E-I-Doh (had this not had a huge continuity goof it couldve gotten an A- from me, so an honorable mention)

& THOH are really hit and miss especially newer ones. One story may be excellent while another poor.

[Bella Drape 'er]

Just have your lists in by the start of April.

great, in two days time

i'll keep this post here if i have time to post a list, if not...meh

[HMS pinafore]

25. The Computer Wore Menace Shoes
24. Guess Who's Coming to Criticize Dinner
23. HOMR
22. Tales From Public Domain
21. New Kids on the Blecch
20. Bart the Mother
19. Moe Baby Blues
18. Mr. Spritz Goes to Washington
17. The Frying Game
16. I, D'oh-bot
15. Treehouse of Horror XI
14. Fraudcast News
13. Marge Simpson In: Screaming Yellow Honkers
12. Poppa's Got a Brand New Badge
11. The Haw-Hawed Couple
10. Behind the Laughter
9. Special Edna
8. Thirty Minutes Over Tokyo
7. C.E.D'oh
6. Trilogy of Error
5. Lisa Gets An 'A'
4. Mom And Pop Art
3. Hungry Hungry Homer
2. Treehouse of Horror IX
1. Mayored to the Mob

[jonnymack]

Hope This isn't too Late:

25. Treehouse of Horror XIII
24. Tales from the Public Domain
23. Catch 'Em If You Can
22. Missionary: Impossible
21. Guess Who's Coming to Criticize Dinner
20. Treehouse of Horror XI
19. Treehouse of Horror X
18. Co-Dependent's Day
17. Homer and Lisa Exchange Cross Words
16. Mayored to the Mob
15. Maximum Homerdrive
14. The Seemingly Never-Ending Story
13. She of Little Faith
12. I D'oh Bot
11. Brother's Little Helper
10. Simpsons Bible Stories
9. Trilogy of Error
8. Behind the Laughter
7. Lard of the Dance
6. E-I-E-D'oh
5. Eternal Moonshine of the Simpson Mind
4. I'm Spelling as Fast as I Can
3. A Mid Summer's Nice Dream
2. Weekend at Burnsies
1. D'ohing in the Wind

[Brad Lascelle]

It's always the last minute entries that knock my favorites out of the Top 50.
EDIT: Actually, scratch that... looks like most of them made it.

[Financial Panther]

All right, we have received 31 lists. It's nearly April now, so I'd appreciate it if a mod could close this thread, and I'll begin calculating the results tomorrow.