Official Season 23 ratings thread

[leprechaun_dan]

Comparing Season 23 to 11...

1. Beyond Blunderdome - 6.3/10, The Falcon and the D'ohman - 7.1/10 [S23]
2. Brother's Little Helper - 7.7/10, Bart Stops to Smell the Roosevelts - 7.7/10 [Equal]
3. Guess Who's Coming to Criticize Dinner? - 8.2/10, Treehouse of Horror XXII - 6.2/10 [S11]
4. Treehouse of Horror X - 8.2/10, Replaceable You - n/a
5. E-I-E-I-D'oh - 7.8/10, The Food Wife - 8.1/10 [S23]
6. Hello Gutter, Hello Fadder - 7.2/10, The Book Job - 8.4/10 [S23]
7. Eight Misbehavin' - 5.6/10, The Man in the Blue Flannel Pants - n/a
8. Take My Wife, Sleaze - 7.5/10, The Ten Per-Cent Solution - n/a
9. Grift of the Magi - 8.5/10, Holidays of Future Passed - 8.9/10 [S23]
10. Little Big Mom - 6.8/10, Politically Inept with Homer Simpson - n/a
11. Faith Off - 6.7/10, The D'oh-cial Network - 6.9/10 [S23]
12. The Mansion Family - 6/10, Moe Goes From Rags to Riches - 3.8/10 [S11]
13. Saddlesore Galactica - 5.2/10, The Daughter Also Rises - n/a
14. Alone Again, Natura-Diddily - 7.1/10, At Long Last Leave - 7.6/10 [S23]
15. Missionary: Impossible - 7.6/10, Exit Through the Kwik-E-Mart - 7.5/10 [S11]
16. Pygmoelian - 8.3/10, How I Wet Your Mother - 8.4/10 [S23]
17. Bart to the Future - 5.7/10, Them Robot - 6.4/10 [S23]
18. Days of Wine and D'oh'ses - 8.6/10, Beware My Cheating Bart - 8.5/10 [S11]
19. Kill the Alligator and Run - 3.7/10, A Totally Fun Thing Bart Will Never Do Again - 6.6/10 [S23]
20. Last Tap Dance in Springfield - 7.8/10, The Spy Who Learned Me - 7.4/10 [S11]
21. It's a Mad Mad Mad Mad Marge - 6.7/10, Ned 'n Edna's Blend - 8/10 [S23]
22. Behind the Laughter - 7.3/10, Lisa Goes Gaga - n/a

I still need to see about five episodes but this is how I'd compare the seasons. So far it looks as if S23 may be slightly better

[parklife]

call me old fashioned, but if you ask me, no episode that i've seen from season twenty three is worth watching (let alone re-watching) and just adds to the further decline of a once brilliant series.

how any of you guys are handing out perfect scores to any of these shows is just so mind boggling to me

[The Governor]

call me old fashioned, but if you ask me, no episode that i've seen from season twenty three is worth watching (let alone re-watching) and just adds to the further decline of a once brilliant series.

how any of you guys are handing out perfect scores to any of these shows is just so mind boggling to me

I grade on a curve. Thr only perfect episode from the past few seasons was Holidays of Future Passed. The Matt Selman episodes are highly overrated, though.

[zach]

[Financial Panther]

Final list!

1) The Falcon and the D'ohman: 10/10

2) The Book Job: 9.5/10

3) Holidays of Future Passed: 8.5/10

4) Ned 'n Edna's Blend: 8/10

5) The Spy Who Learned Me: 8/10

6) At Long Last Leave: 8/10

7) The Ten-Per-Cent Solution: 7.5/10

8) Beware My Cheating Bart: 7.5/10

9) The Daughter Also Rises: 7/10

10) Exit Through the Kwik-E-Mart: 7/10

11) The Food Wife: 6.5/10

12) Lisa Goes Gaga: 5/10

13) How I Wet Your Mother: 5/10

14) Replaceable You: 4.5/10

15) Them, Robot: 4/10

16) Bart Stops to Smell the Roosevelts: 4/10

17) Treehouse of Horror XXII: 4/10

18) Politically Inept, With Homer Simpson: 3.5/10

19) Moe Goes From Rags to Riches: 3.5/10

20) The Man in the Blue Flannel Pants: 3/10

21) The D'oh-cial Network: 1.5/10

22) A Totally Fun Thing that Bart Will Never Do Again: .5/10

[Prune Tracy]

Well, here's the three episodes I've seen:

The Falcon and the D'ohman: C+
Lisa Goes Gaga: D+
The Daughter Also Rises: D

Doesn't really want to make me check out any more of the season.

[Financial Panther]

What a shame. Come to NoHomers, call yourself a fan...and watch a grand total of three episodes from the season.

[Alex_Of_Darkness]

Season 23 :

Holidays of future passed : (17/20) - 4,25/5
How I Wet Your Mother : (16/20) - 4/5
The Book Job : (15/20) - 3,75/5
At Long Last Leave : (15/20) - 3,75/5
Beware My Cheating Bart : (15/20) - 3,75/5
The Daughter Also Rises : (14/20) - 3,5/5
Replaceable you : (14/20) - 3,5/5
Ned 'N Edna Blend : (14/20) - 3,5/5
The Food Wife : (13/20) - 3,25/5
A Totally Fun Thing That Bart Will Never Do Again : (13/20) - 3,25/5
Exit Through the Kwik-E-Mart : (13/20) - 3,25/5
The D'oh-cial Network : (12/20) - 3/5
Bart stops to smell the Roosevelts : (11/20) - 2,75/5
Lisa Goes Gaga : (10/20) - 2,5/5
The Man in Blue Flannel Pants : (10/20) - 2,5/5
Moe goes from rags to riches : (9/20) - 2,25/5
The Falcon and the D'ohman : (8/20) - 2/5
Them, Robot : (8/20) - 2/5
The Ten Per-cent Solution : (6/20) - 1,5/5
Treehouse of horror XXII : (5/20) - 1,25/5
The Spy Who Learned Me : (4/20) - 1/5
Politically inept, with Homer Simpson : (3/20) - 0,75/5

Average : (11,14/20) - 2,78/5

[Prune Tracy]

What a shame. Come to NoHomers, call yourself a fan...and watch a grand total of three episodes from the season.

I'm sorry if I don't want to watch the season and be disappointed? I'm sorry if I want to watch GOOD episodes?

[Financial Panther]

Sorry bud. Just giving you trouble. I guess we can't ALL be as devoted as me.

[zach]

well now that the season is over, i'll make my ratings. but comparing it to season 11 is just ridiculous.

[irvine_11]

Final list:

Holidays of Future Passed - A
The Book Job - B+
The Food Wife - B
How I Wet Your Mother - B
The Daughter Also Rises - C+
Ned 'n' Edna's Blend - C+
Replacable You - C+
Beware My Cheating Bart - C
The Spy Who Learned Me - C-
Moe Goes From Rags to Riches - C-
Exit Through the Kwik-E-Mart - D+
Bart Stops to Smell the Roosevelts - D+
The Ten Percent Solution - D+
The Falcon and the D'ohman - D
At Long Last Leave - D
A Totally Fun Thing Bart Will Never Do Again - D
The Man in the Blue Flannel Pants - D
Treehouse of Horror XXII - D-
Politically Inept, with Homer Simpson - F
Them, Robot - F
Lisa Goes Gaga - F
The D'ohcial Network - F

I'll write a review for this season later.

[Ruffles]

Of the episodes I've rated:

1. Holidays of Future Passed 10/10
2. At Long Last Leave 9/10
3. How I Wet Your Mother 9/10
4. Bart Stops to Smell the Roosevelts 8/10
5. Exit Through the Kwik-E-Mart 8/10
6. Ned 'N' Edna's Blend 8/10
7. The Daughter Also Rises 7/10
8. Replaceable You 5/10
9. The D'oh-cial Network 5/10
10. Them, Robot 4/10
11. Moe Goes from Rags to Riches 3/10
12. Politically Inept, with Homer Simpson 3/10
13. Lisa Goes Gaga 2/10

[Mozy]

Final Season 23 Ratings:

The Spy Who Learned Me– A
The Falcon and the D'ohman- A
How I Wet Your Mother– B+
The Book Job- B+
The Food Wife- B+
Holidays of Future Passed- B
At Long Last Leave- B-
The Ten Percent Solution- C+
Lisa Goes Gaga- C+
Treehouse of Horror XXII- C
Ned 'n' Edna's Blend- C
Exit Through the Kwik-E-Mart- C-
The Daughter Also Rises- C-
Politically Inept, with Homer Simpson- D+
Beware My Cheating Bart- D+
The Man in the Blue Flannel Pants– D
Replacable You- D
Bart Stops to Smell the Roosevelts- D
Moe Goes From Rags to Riches– D-
Them, Robot- F
The D'ohcial Network– F
A Totally Fun Thing Bart Will Never Do Again- F

[Financial Panther]

For the most part, that list deserves a thumbs-up!

[The Governor]

Looking back...

The Falcon and the D'ohman: 2.5/5

Bart Stops to Smell the Roosevelts: 2/5

Treehouse of Horror XXII: 1/5
--worst THoH, so far.

Replaceable You: 2/5

The Food Wife: 2/5
--not horrible, but really overrated

The Book Job: 4/5
--the only decent Selman produced episode

The Man in the Blue Flannel Pants: 2/5

The Ten-Per-Cent Solution: 3/5

Holidays of Future Passed: 5/5
--best S23 episode by a landslide

Politically Inept With Homer Simpson: 3/5

The D'oh-cial Network: 1/5
--Springface....ewww.

Moe Goes From Rags to Riches: 2/5
--On second thought, I graded it too high originally.

The Daughter Also Rises: 2/5

At Long Last Leave: 2/5
--Should've stayed gone.

Exit Through the Kwik-E-Mart: 4/5

How I Wet Your Mother: 2/5

Them, Robot: 2/5

Beware My Cheating Bart: 3/5

A Totally Fun Thing That Bart Will Never Do Again: .5/5
--Worst episode of the Season. Lady Gaga in the finale was guaranteed fail, but this had potential and it blew it.

The Spy Who Learned Me: 4/5

Ned 'N' Edna's Blend: 3/5

Lisa Goes Gaga: 1/5
--Set you expectations low...so low, you're almost walking on them.

[leprechaun_dan]

well now that the season is over, i'll make my ratings. but comparing it to season 11 is just ridiculous.

How so? Both are equally as bad as each other

Updated list (of the ones I've seen):

4-5
3-4
2-3
0-2

Holidays of Future Passed - 8.9/10 or 4.5/5
Beware My Cheating Bart - 8.5/10 or 4.3/5
How I Wet Your Mother - 8.4/10 or 4.2/5
The Book Job - 8.3/10 or 4.2/5
The Daughter Also Rises - 8.3/10 or 4.1/5
Ned 'n' Edna's Blend - 8.1/10 or 4/5
The Food Wife - 7.9/10 or 3.9/5
Bart Stops to Smell the Roosevelts - 7.7/10 or 3.9/5
At Long Last Leave - 7.6/10 or 3.8/5
Exit Through the Kwik-E-Mart - 7.5/10 or 3.7/5
The Falcon and the D'ohman - 7.4/10 or 3.7/5
The Spy Who Learned Me - 7.3/10 or 3.6/5
A Totally Fun Thing Bart Will Never Do Again - 6.7/10 or 3.3/5
Them, Robot - 6.5/10 or 3.2/5
The D'oh-cial Network - 6.4/10 or 3.2/5
Lisa Goes Gaga - 6.3/10 or 3.1/5
Treehouse of Horror XXII - 6/10 or 3/5
Moe Goes From Rags to Riches - 3.6/10 or 1.8/5

All the rest I have yet to view

[Oh, that's raspberry!]

The Falcon and the D'ohman - 3.5/5
Bart Stops to Smell the Roosevelts - 3.5/5
Treehouse of Horror XXII - 3/5
Replaceable You - 3/5
The Food Wife - 4/5
The Book Job - 4/5
The Man in the Blue Flannel Pants - 4/5
The Ten-Per-Cent Solution - 4/5
Holidays of Future Passed - 5/5 BEST
Politically Inept, With Homer Simpson - 3/5
The D'oh-cial Network - 1.5/5 WORST
Moe Goes From Rags to Riches - 3/5
The Daughter Also Rises - 4/5
At Long Last Leave - 4/5
Exit Through the Kwik-E-Mart - 4/5
How I Wet Your Mother - 4/5
Them, Robot - 2.5/5
Beware My Cheating Bart - 4.5/5
A Totally Fun Thing That Bart Will Never Do Again - 3/5
The Spy Who Learned Me - 3.5/5
Ned 'N' Edna's Blend - 3/5
Lisa Goes Gaga - 2/5

Several of these grades are based off only a single watch so...they should be taken accordingly.

[uruguayo]

The Falcon and the D'ohman 5/5
Bart Stops to Smell the Roosevelts 4/5
Treehouse of Horror XXII 4/5
Replaceable You 4/5
The Food Wife 4/5
The Book Job 3/5
The Man in the Blue Flannel Pants 4/5
The Ten-Per-Cent Solution 3.5/5
Holidays of Future Passed 5/5
Politically Inept, With Homer Simpson 3.5/5
The D'oh-cial Network 4/5
Moe Goes From Rags to Riches 3/5
The Daughter Also Rises 3.5/5
At Long Last Leave 5/5
Exit Through the Kwik-E-Mart 4/5
How I Wet Your Mother 5/5
Them, Robot 3.5/5
Beware My Cheating Bart 4/5
A Totally Fun Thing That Bart Will Never Do Again 4/5
The Spy Who Learned Me 3.5/5
Ned 'N' Edna's Blend 4/5
Lisa goes Gaga 4/5

Average: 87.5/100 - 4/5

[zach]

The Falcon and the D'ohman: F
Bart Stops to Smell the Roosevelts: F
Treehouse of Horror XXII: F
Replaceable You: F
The Food Wife: F
The Book Job: F
The Man in the Blue Flannel Pants: F
The Ten-Per-Cent Solution: F
Holidays of Future Passed: F
Politically Inept, With Homer Simpson: F
The D'oh-cial Network: F
Moe Goes From Rags to Riches: F
The Daughter Also Rises: F
At Long Last Leave: F
Exit Through the Kwik-E-Mart: F
How I Wet Your Mother: F
Them, Robot: F
Beware My Cheating Bart: F
A Totally Fun Thing That Bart Will Never Do Again: F
The Spy Who Learned Me: F
Ned 'N' Edna's Blend: F
Lisa goes Gaga: F

[MDB]

The Falcon and the D'ohman: F
Bart Stops to Smell the Roosevelts: F
Treehouse of Horror XXII: F
Replaceable You: F
The Food Wife: F
The Book Job: F
The Man in the Blue Flannel Pants: F
The Ten-Per-Cent Solution: F
Holidays of Future Passed: F
Politically Inept, With Homer Simpson: F
The D'oh-cial Network: F
Moe Goes From Rags to Riches: F
The Daughter Also Rises: F
At Long Last Leave: F
Exit Through the Kwik-E-Mart: F
How I Wet Your Mother: F
Them, Robot: F
Beware My Cheating Bart: F
A Totally Fun Thing That Bart Will Never Do Again: F
The Spy Who Learned Me: F
Ned 'N' Edna's Blend: F
Lisa goes Gaga: F

At least the F in Exit Through the Kwik-E-Mart is not in bold type

[MDB]

Anyway, mi list:

1) The Food Wife: A
2) Holidays Of Future Passed: A
3) How I Wet Your Mother: A-
4) A Totally Fun Thing That Bart Will Never Do Again: B+
5) Bart Stops to Smell the Roosevelts: B+
6) The Book Job: B+
7) The Ten-Per-Cent Solution: B
8) The Daughter Also Rises: B
9) The Spy Who Learned Me: B
10) The Falcon And The D'ohman: B
11) Ned 'n' Edna's Blend: B
12) Replaceable You: B
13) Beware My Cheating Bart: B-
14) The D’oh-cial Network: C+
15) Treehouse Of Horror XXII: C+
16) Long Last Leave: C+
17) The Man In The Blue Flannel Pants: C+
18) Them, Robot: C+
19) Lisa goes gaga C+
20) Exit Through the Kwik-E-Mart: C
21) Politically Inept, With Homer Simpson: C-
22) Moe Goes From Rags To Riches: D+

[irvine_11]

Holidays of Future Passed: F

Explanation, please.

[zach]

in due time.

[Alex_Of_Darkness]

This thread reminds me that I have to continue to review episodes! I just do season 1, 4, 7 and 21 with real critic and real note...

[Handsome B. Wonderful]

Explanation, please.

Eh, wouldn't surprise me.

[zach]

i just watched it again. found it relentlessly boring. not a single thing that i found humorous. it was a struggle to get through the whole thing. will never watch it again.

[Comicshow MolemanBob]

The Book Job: F

This is the one that really deserves an explanation...

[zach]

there is no way i'm re-watching that garbage episode. every episode from this season is completely boring and humorless. every episode is a chore to get through. i just saw 2 minutes of that gaga episode in syndication and i nearly killed myself.

[Comicshow MolemanBob]

i just saw 2 minutes of that gaga episode in syndication and i nearly killed myself.

Well no one can blame you for that...