Season-by-Season Episode Ranking Game

[Bella Drape 'er]

just one more to go...

[Nauru-1]

Okay here's the list for season 21. Thanks to everyone who sent in their lists. Feel free to send yours for season 22 whenever.

1. O Brother, Where Bart Thou? - 120
2. Postcards From the Wedge - 112
3. Once Upon A Time In Springfield - 105
4. Chief of Hearts - 102
5. Treehouse of Horror XX - 93
6. To Surveil With Love - 92
7. American History X-cellent - 89
8. The Squirt and the Whale - 88
9. The Bob Next Door - 86
10. Pranks and Greens - 73
11. Moe Letter Blues - 71
12. Stealing First Base - 69
13. Million Dollar Maybe - 61
14. The Color Yellow - 58
15. Homer the Whopper - 57
15. The Great Wife Hope - 57
17. Rednecks and Broomsticks - 56
18. Thursdays With Abie - 53
19. The Devil Wears Nada - 52
20. Boy Meets Curl - 48
21. Bart Gets a 'Z' - 47
22. Judge Me Tender - 37
23. The Greatest Story Ever D'ohed - 20

[The Spruce Moose]

okay, who didn't put The Greatest Story Ever D'ohed last? Or is it really that bad a season?

[Nauru-1]

Four out of six lists had it last. Its highest placing on any list was 13th. I'm just glad it ended up where it should be in the end.

[Bella Drape 'er]

No love for Boy Meets Curl

And The Bob Next Door is ridiculously high...

Aside from that, a good list

[Financial Panther]

Its highest placing on any list was 13th.

That was my list, I believe. I just don't find it that terrible. I think it has a few good jokes thrown in there, and yes, the tour guide was the most annoying character in the history of the show, and the ending wasn't too great, but I didn't really find anything else in the episode too bad.

[Jesse Pinkman]

never realized bart gets a z was so hated. replace that with boy meets curl and the bottom three would be exactly as it was on my list.

bob next door as number 9? interesting.

i was actually debating on whether or not to have Greatest Story as my last; I was going to place it somewhere else in my list, but i figured if i did and it wasn't the final placed episode in the season, everyone would start bitching at me for 'tampering the results' or whatever.

[Financial Panther]

bob next door as number 9? interesting.

[Jesse Pinkman]

yes, i had you in mind when i made that comment FP

[Bella Drape 'er]

so we move onto season 22 now?

[Oh, that's raspberry!]

Some interesting results to be sure, I disagree with several listings but Postcards from the Wedge being so high both surprises and pleases me. But then 6 lists is such a small sample size I suppose....

[Gladys the Groovy Mule]

so is this still going?

[Financial Panther]

If you PM zartok a list, he may have enough to post season 22.

[Gladys the Groovy Mule]

done and done. And I mean done

[Bartesque]

If you PM zartok a list, he may have enough to post season 22.

You mean Nauru?

[Financial Panther]

Nauru! I don't know why I said zartok...

[Gladys the Groovy Mule]

doesn't matter I sent the list to whoever posted up the results for Season 21

[Nauru-1]

Thanks for the additional lists. Here are the results for season 22. Still don't get the like for MoneyBART, but overall I think the results are pretty fair.

1. The Great Simpsina - 121
2. Homer the Father - 120
3. Homer Scissorhands - 108
4. Lisa Simpson, This Isn't Your Life - 105
5. Loan-a Lisa - 93
6. Moms I'd Like to Forget - 92
7. The Blue and the Gray - 90
8. MoneyBART - 87
9. 500 Keys - 82
10. The Ned-Liest Catch - 69
11. The Fight Before Christmas - 68
12. Donnie Fatso - 64
13. The Scorpion's Tale - 56
14. The Real Housewives of Fat Tony - 52
15. Angry Dad: The Movie - 49
15. Flaming Moe - 49
17. Treehouse of Horror XXI - 47
18. A Midsummer's Nice Dream - 46
19. Elementary School Musical - 42
20. Love is a Many-Strangled Thing - 32
21. The Fool Monty - 30
22. How Munched is That Birdie in the Window? - 18

[Oh, that's raspberry!]

I still don't agree with the hate for Birdie and Homer the Father should've been one. Aside from that nothing that surprising aside from a Season 12 episode apparently being included

[Bartesque]

I don't see how Birdie could be 10 points behind the two abominations above it.

[Bella Drape 'er]

1. The Great Simpsina - 121
2. Homer the Father - 120
3. Homer Scissorhands - 108

Homer the Father is average at best, but the other two are so forgettable.

I don't think I even finished watching The Great Simpsina because it was so boring...

[HMS pinafore]

wow 22 is a bad season, the top 7 or so I would call forgettable, and the rest was utter shit

[Bella Drape 'er]

So now that we've ranked all the finished seasons, is this game on hiatus until season 23 ends or something?

[Company Picnic]

The Scorpion's Tale, Angry Dad: The Movie and 500 Keys should be lower - but most of the season is quite awful. Otherwise, it's about right I can't really rate most of the post-classic seasons though, they have very few episodes that inspire me to put them towards the top.

[Financial Panther]

I wish Donnie Fatso wasn't so low, but other than that, I mainly agree with the list.

[Rich Uncle Skeleton]

Elementary School Musical should have been at the bottom. Worst. Episode. Ever.

[irvine_11]

Wow, I'm glad Simpsina made the top. I didn't realize people liked that episode that much.

[Nauru-1]

Yeah we can do season 23 when it ends. I'm well behind in this year's episode though so it'll be tough to come up with a ranking.