Brian Scully

[BGod84]

Which would you prefer? Brian Scully's writing for the simpsons? or family guy?

[Jesse Pinkman]

His resume on The Simpsons:

Lost Our Lisa {eh, OK}
Sunday Cruddy Sunday {with a couple other writers}
Make Room For Lisa {yea, you all know how I felt about this}

His resume on Family Guy:

I Dream of Jesus {haven't seen all of it}
Big Man on Hippocampus {haven't seen any}

Not the most impressive resume by any standards. I'll say Simpsons just because I haven't seen Big Man, and I haven't seen all of I Dream Of Jesus

[Green Man]

[Dylan]

i dream of jesus was awesome

[Dark Homer]

lost our lisa and make room for lisa are two of the better episodes of the scully years

that jesus episode of family guy was terrible and i haven't seen the other one

[qwertyuio]

lost our lisa and make room for lisa are two of the better episodes of the scully years

This, but Sunday, Cruddy Sunday was dreadful. I'll give Family Guy the benefit of the doubt.

[emanuellburnell]

Lost our Lisa and Make room for Lisa are really great episodes of the Scully era. Family Guy episode I Dream of Jesus was total crap, it don't deserve any benefit what so ever.

[Bella Drape 'er]

Lost Our Lisa was good and Sunday Cruddy Sunday was...ok.

I actually really like Make Room For Lisa, particularly the third act.


The Jesus episode was absolutely disgusting, and I'm horrified they brought it back in Big Man on Hippocampus. Hippocampus was better than the Jesus episode, but really not as good as any of the Simpson episodes he did.

[Léo Pard]

Lost Our Lisa and Sunday, Cruddy Sunday are decent, but Make Room for Lisa is one of my least favorites from season 10.
However, I haven't seen his episodes in Family Guy.

[Nauru-1]

I don't know if I've seen the Family Guy episodes. He only wrote three and one I imagine he only contributed so much since it was co-written. Lost Our Lisa was decent enough so I'll go with that.

[cinco]

"Make Room for Lisa" contains this sentence:

Lisa:I know we love each other, Dad,
but we're two very different people and, much as I hate to
say it, as time goes on, we'll probably just drift further
and further apart.

And it breaks me apart every time I hear it.
So I'd say the Simpsons for now.
But I will watch "I Dream of Jesus" tonight and than I can make proper judgement.

[Moe Nopoly]

must say i like the three episodes Lost Our Lisa, Sunday Cruddy Sunday and Make Room For Lisa, so i like his work for the simpsons more.

[cinco]

Watched "I Dream of Jesus" yesterday. Better than "Sunday Cruddy Sunday (but wat isn't), worse than "Lost our Lisa" and "Make Room for Lisa".

[emanuellburnell]

I will take "Lost our Lisa" and "Sunday Cruddy Sunday because these or much better episodes, then that episode of "I Dream of Jesus" from Family Guy.