View Poll Results: How would you rate HABF17?

Voters
221. You may not vote on this poll
  • 5/5

    14 6.33%
  • 4/5

    78 35.29%
  • 3/5

    75 33.94%
  • 2/5

    36 16.29%
  • 1/5

    18 8.14%
Page 1 of 6 123456 LastLast
Results 1 to 30 of 163



Thread: Rate/Review Treehouse of Horror XVII



(Users Browsing this Thread: )

  1. #1


    Rate/Review Treehouse of Horror XVII

    Written by Peter Gaffney (all three segments), Directed by David Silverman & Matthew C. Faughnan

    Married To The Blob - A meteor falls to Earth and reveals a green goo that Homer mistakes for a marshmallow. After Homer eats the goo, he turns into a rampaging blob with a never-ending appetite that even guest voice Dr. Phil McGraw can't stop.
    You Gotta Know When To Golem - Bart brings Golem, guest voice Richard Lewis as a legendary monster from Jewish folklore, to life and forces him to carry out his ghastly bidding. But when the creature is finally freed of his evil-doing, Marge, Bart and Lisa create a female monster (guest voice Fran Drescher) that captures Golem's heart.
    The Day The Earth Looked Stupid - A spoof of "War of the Worlds." Set in 1938, the citizens of Springfield - once fooled by the Orson Welles radio broadcast - react with nonchalance to a real invasion by slobbering cyclopses Kang and Kodos.


    Leaked episode reviews and discussion can be found starting here. Still, this thread will open as always once the episode is done airing on the East Coast.

  2. #2
    Stonecutter coltonwiggum's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2005
    Location
    Where Stephen Harper precepts.
    Posts
    2,187


    3/5
    This episode had a lot of good and a bit of crap. Which obviously isn't perfect, but still (I think) deserves a 3/5. The intro was awesome. The first segment had a good beggining, bad middle, and meh ending. 2/5. The second segment had a fabulous beggining, a good middle, and a meh ending. 3/5. The final segmentwas very good throughout, with lots of funny jokes. 5/5. And according to my calculations, two plus three plus five divided by three equals 3.3. BTW, I loved the Arby's joke. And I thought the detail of showing that owl on the chimney was cool.
    Last edited by coltonwiggum; 11-26-2006 at 07:23 PM.
    she didnt exactly read shrek the 3rd, which apparently exists as some sort of companion book for a pixar movie. no, this would probably take several minutes (perhaps 10), and would have ultimately depricated the shrek 3 cinematic experience

    she merely looked at the book

    she saw it, perhaps in the childrens section of a barnes & noble, registered it in her mind as being in existance, and filed it away for later as the subject for a post on BOOKS YOUVE READ. only she just looked at it. and it was shrek 3

    in a way its the saddest post ive ever read

    -toxic shock syndrome

  3. #3
    *RIP Marcia Wallace* TriforceBun's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2004
    Location
    Louisiana
    Posts
    4,183


    They took out the line!!

    MARRIED TO THE BLOB: Not bad. I really liked the animation of Homer absorbing the goo back into his mouth, even if it did go on too long. And the musical montage actually worked well this time, with fairly clever lyrics coupled with above-average sight gags and animation. Some parts fell a little flat, but overall, it was a rather inoffensive little segment with a funny last line (though why wasn't Homer green at the end?). B-

    YOU GOTTA KNOW WHEN TO GOLEM: Probably my favorite of the three, this one had a couple good laughs, like HDTV, and Homer's "Hi, Milhouse." I think throughout the episode (and in the greater scope of things, the whole show nowadays), some gags could've afforded to be less subtle. For instance, the scene in Bart's bedroom could've ended after he said, "Homer's WALLS," and the joke would've still been effective. B

    THE DAY THE EARTH LOOKED STUPID: Better than the first viewing. I dug the animation, and although the story pacing was still a little off, the nostalgia jokes were pretty decent, and the Iraq thing--though slightly tacked-on--was a lot more effective without that stupid last line that they THANKFULLY decided to cut. Well done for the most part.

    4/5
    Last edited by TriforceBun; 11-05-2006 at 05:37 PM.
    My Nintendo webcomic,

  4. #4
    Galalimit
    Guest


    They took out the Iraq line, I noticed.

    One of the worst thoh's ever. Pure garbage. D-

  5. #5
    scissors on his fuckin head That Jerk's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2004
    Location
    The Corporate Institutional Bank of Time
    Posts
    1,408


    whewwww

    What a sigh of relief this episode was. After a dismal past four episodes, I was losing hope. And we can all agree that the Halloween episodes haven't been brilliant in about ten years. This episode was quite innovative though, and each story was great.

    intro - The TFTC intro was a smart idea. Loved all the gags (especially the bunnies). The March of Dimes skeleton had me nostalgic for tombstones somehow.
    4/5
    -------------
    act one (blob) - One of those tales that you wonder how they never thought of it before. The snot sucking was so gross! Perfect halloween yuckness. The plot progresses nicely. I really don't like these pun lines "Let me have a lick at you." Is that supposed to be funny because it's so corny, or are we really supposed to believe it is clever? Even if it's meant to be satire, these lines are making the show sound way too much like cliché sitcom #17.

    - Homer drooling over teenagers was indirectly kinda perverted.

    - Phil's cameo didn't bother me. They had a few good exchanges, and I liked Wiggum's interjection. The part where he ate him though didn't flow, and was kinda edited oddly.
    4/5
    -----------------------
    act two (golem) - I was really surprised with this one. The second story lately has always been pretty lame (Jack The Ripper, zombie cowboys), but this plot was pretty original and fun. The only thing that I felt weighed it down was too many Krusty "show biz" tangents, which took away form the Halloween feeling. Also, lines direct as "shoebox of blow" really put me off. I don't have any problem with Krusty having drug addictions, I just wish they would be more clever about it.

    - Many of the jokes were predictable (Golem shooting people at the comedy club, Homer appearing instead of Golem, Wiggum dismissing the case), but probably because we are way too keen on Simpsons humor. They're still good jokes.

    - The only bit i didn't like was Skinner's "I may be bifurcated..." Talk about dragging a bit on too long.

    Still, a well done story
    4/5
    ---------------------------------
    act three (war of the worlds) - Old-timey jokes galore! Perfect bit.

    - best gag: Big Band Stu!
    5/5

    Best Halloween ep in years, and first good episode since last season's "The Monkey Suit"


    Wow... I can't believe they actually cut the last line (It was a smart move though). No Homers is going to become drunk with influence now!
    Last edited by That Jerk; 11-05-2006 at 05:57 PM.

  6. #6
    slack jawed gawker the 'house always wins's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2006
    Location
    the windy apple
    Posts
    650


    2/5 ...seemed like the entire episode was 10 minutes long....so many damn commercials...

    the episode itself was pretty weak compared to most of the THOH's from years past in my opinion...the only segment i liked was the war of the worlds bit, and really only its allusions to the war in iraq
    Give the great Unwashed a pair of oversized breasts and a happy ending,
    and they'll 'oink' for more every time.
    - C.M. Burns

    For every moment of triumph, for every instance of beauty, many souls must be trampled. - Hunter S. Thompson

  7. #7
    Mmmmm, hotdog. J-Spot's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2006
    Location
    St. Louis
    Posts
    413


    What exactly was the line they cut out?

  8. #8
    Banned Reservoir Dog's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2006
    Location
    Seattle
    Posts
    2,120


    What was the Iraq line? I didnt see the leaked episode.

  9. #9
    Stonecutter blueguy's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2003
    Location
    Minneapolis
    Posts
    4,074


    The first two were meh, but the last one was pretty good. 3/5 overall.

    What I found more interesting is that it appears the show is being animated in widescreen.

    Last week I was toying with the settings on my HDTV because I had a lot of overscan, so I brought everything in a lot. Well, during the show, the black bars on the left and right didn't go all the way to the top, so I saw a very slim line above it and it was pretty clear that there was animation there that was just being covered up. I wonder when the show will finally begin broadcasting it that way, or do we need to wait for the DVD?
    Despite all my rage, I'm still just a rat in a cage.

  10. #10


    The line was, "This is a lot like Iraq will be."

    And I am so happy they cut it.
    Quote Originally Posted by simpsonsfan20 View Post
    My view: You can show pictures of people in the nude, you can show pictures of people having sex, you can even show kids naked, but SHOW HOMER 'DOING IT' WITH LISA AND I'LL HUNT YOU DOWN.

  11. #11
    board militant™ joe's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2002
    Location
    Cobble Hill, Brooklyn
    Posts
    31,195


    better then the past few years... the last segment was great.
    Heckling a Puppet show.


  12. #12
    pretty rad
    Join Date
    Apr 2002
    Location
    taco town
    Posts
    18,339


    Third one was the best. I liked the depiction of Springfield 1938, and they did the right thing by getting Maurice LaMarche. There were a surprising number of guest stars, but it seemed to work out.
    newest fad! twitter | the photodump | facebook
    [00:29] AlonsoWDC: hank hill would cum out of his mouth in disgust if he were here right now

  13. #13
    SuperFriend Homer Jay's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2004
    Location
    Outside Boston
    Posts
    6,737


    I really liked this episode. It felt like the classic THoH, only not as good. There were a few great lines, but a number bombed. The segments all had a number of strong points, but none of them was great. I didn't mind the liberator line as much as I would have thought, but Homer's "Flanders?" line was great. I was a little disappointed that they didn't end the episode with "We'll Meet Again"

    B Probably the season's best so far. It seemed to have more ambition that earlier ones this season

  14. #14
    I'm baaaack! Patches O'houlihan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2001
    Location
    Wisconsin: "More bars in more places."
    Posts
    15,472
    Blog Entries
    2


    Married To The Blob - All gags, no plot, but pretty interesting. B-


    You Gotta Know When To Golem - Mostly plot, the least amount of gags. B-


    The Day The Earth Looked Stupid - Thank goodness they removed that 'duh' line at the end. The best animated (apart from the opening), and the best jokes, IMO. A-

    Overall, I'd say 4/5, slightly above average, with no 'bad' shorts this year.


    Well, ya'know if you stay positive and forget about trivial things like "proper characterization," "Satire," and "emotional depth" watching new Simpsons episodes can be a seemingly enjoyable lie.

  15. #15
    The cosmic ballet goes on.. Radioactive Man's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2003
    Posts
    2,269


    Last segment was good. The first two were horrible.

  16. #16
    The Chunnel's gonna blow!
    Join Date
    Jul 2006
    Location
    Ohio
    Posts
    470


    Not too bad. This was definitely better than last year's THOH. Still, it wasn't all too funny. The Blob segment was pretty boring, the Golem one was better, but still had some bad, unfunny jokes in it. The Day the Earth Looked Stupid was the best one, IMO. Overall, I'd give it a 3/5.
    Season 18 Grades
    The Mook, the Chef, the Wife and Her Homer: C+
    Jazzy and the Pussycats: D-
    Please Homer, Don't Hammer 'Em...: F
    Treehouse of Horror XVII: C-
    G.I. D'oh: B-
    Moe 'N' A Lisa: B
    Ice Cream of Margie (With the Light Blue Hair): B
    The Haw-Hawed Couple: B
    Kill Gil: Vols. 1 & 2: C
    The Wife Aquatic: N/A
    Revenge is a Dish Best Served Three Times: C
    Little Big Girl: A-
    Springfield Up: A-
    Yokel Chords: B
    Rome-old and Juli-eh: C-
    Homerazzi: B
    Marge Gamer: B-
    The Boys of Bummer: B
    Crook and Ladder: C-
    Stop Or My Dog Will Shoot!: C-
    24 Minutes: A-
    You Kent Always Say What You Want: C

    Season Rankings
    4>7>3>8>6>5>2>9>1>10>15>13>14>12>18>11>17>16

  17. #17
    Itchy/Hillary in '08
    Join Date
    Nov 2006
    Posts
    121


    Very good episode: 4/5

    The second one was the best, followed by the third then the first. I was so glad they had the scary names, and was anyone else tense when they were waiting for the Iraq line. I was waiting for them to say it and it felt like forever and then they didn't!

  18. #18
    Junior Camper
    Join Date
    Aug 2005
    Location
    Houston, TX
    Posts
    134


    I hated the Blob. The second one was funny but it's plot kinda pointless. I loved the third one though.

    3/5
    Lost Airs Wed. 10/9c on ABC!

    Lisa is a nut, she has a rubber butt, every time she turns around it goes putt-putt!

  19. #19
    Junior Camper
    Join Date
    Feb 2005
    Posts
    149


    It was decent.

  20. #20
    post brody's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2005
    Location
    ky
    Posts
    9,444


    Certainly an improvement on the last two years, this THOH was, but yet, it was missing something.

    Married to the Blob
    This was an ok enough segment, despite the rather thin plot. However, the problem is that watching Homer go around and eat everyone just isn't very
    interesting. It's the same problem with "Survival of the Fattest" from last year, it isn't interesting to watch the same thing happen to different people for the majority of the segment. I did enjoy the "Baby Got Back" remake, though. As for Dr. Phil, he had a couple of good one-liners, and the joke about Homer saying he tasted just like Jeffrey Tambor was funny, but they need to stop having guest star's play themselves in THOH's, in ruins the mood.

    C+

    You Gotta Know When to Golem
    This certainly started out well, and I thought that it had a good creepy atmosphere. Then in went crashing down in quality, with the stupid "Golem wants love" plotline. They couldn't think of anything scary or exciting. No, it had to be something involving love. Fran Drescher was also completely needless. This is probably one of my least favorite segments ever.


    D+

    The Day the Earth Looked Stupid
    Definitely the best segment, and one that was actually somewhat scary. The direction was phenomenal. Everything, the effects, the picture, was great. The plotline with the townspeople going mad was good, especially the different types of jokes they did regarding their insanity. I'm not sure who did the Orson Welle's voice (probably Shearer), but it was very good. The conclusion of the segment, with Kang and Kodos, was very effective. This saved the episode.

    B+

    Overall:
    C+

  21. #21
    Virgin Colada! *No Rum breadharrity's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2005
    Location
    NJ
    Posts
    485


    I'm too much of a simpsons fanboy so...

    4/5

  22. #22
    . TheForbiddenDonut's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2006
    Location
    Georgia
    Posts
    11,786


    I'm going to review assuming that the first two segments were the same as the leaked version, but I saw the last segment as it aired (hooray for the last line being cut!)

    Married to the Blob- Average. Some weak moments, especially the music montage. The opening, however, was reminiscent of classic THOH, containing a nice dark feel. Homer as the blob was a bit disturbing, but had its moments, the best part of the segment being Homer's ''I'll SAVOR you!". Dr. Phil's appearance actually wasn't that bad. After getting past the fact that it was entirely pointless, I actually found it pretty amusing. I didn't exactly enjoy the ending, but I guess it's the best way to end such a bizarre segment.
    -B

    You Gotta Know When To Golem- I really disliked this segment. Yeah, there were some okay jokes, but most were awful. The whole 'kick Homer's walls' joke wasn't the least bit funny, as well as Skinner getting yo-yo-ed in half. And the ending was awful. I mean, when Jean can't stand to put any worthwhile emotion into the regular characters, why drag out a painfully sappy scene between a talking Golem and some she-golem with possibly the most annoying voice ever heard on the show.
    -D+

    The Day the Earth Looked Stoopid- Very well-done segment. Other than the tacked on Iraq thing, the segment was near-flawless. Some great lines accompanied by a nice 30s setting makes for a very well-animated and funny segment. Still, the acting like animals scene marred it a bit.
    -B+

    Probably averages out to around a B- or a 4/5.

  23. #23
    Don't bad-mouth the head! Xt'Tapalatakettle's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2006
    Posts
    3,725


    Married to the Blob
    I found this to probably be the funniest segment. Sir Mix-Alot's song wasn't anything cringeworthy, nor was Dr. Phil, though I would've liked him to be eaten much much sooner. The ending was pretty messed up, but funny. 3.75/5

    You Gotta Know When To Golem
    Meh. Decent until the Golem spoke. There was probably one or two lines I laughed at from Richard Lewis, but it seemed wasted. 2.75/5

    The Day The Earth Looked Stupid
    Fabulous, up there for the best THoH segment in the Jean era. The jokes were on (the rioting, Disco Stu, etc.). The ending was very heavy-handed, which is what made it great. It actually felt eerie at the end. 4.75/5

    Overall 4/5 Excellent.
    Last edited by Xt'Tapalatakettle; 11-05-2006 at 06:21 PM.
    Favorite Episodes (by Season): Season 1: Krusty Gets Busted, Call of the Simpsons
    Season 2: Blood Feud, Itchy & Scratchy & Marge, Bart the Daredevil
    Season 3: Radio Bart, Burns Verkaufen der Kraftwerk, Bart the Murderer
    Season 4: Homer the Heretic, Krusty Gets Kancelled, The Front
    Season 5: Cape Feare, The Last Temptation of Homer, Sweet Seymour Skinner's Badasssss Song
    Season 6: Bart's Girlfriend, Bart of Darkness, Homie the Clown
    Season 7: Summer of 4ft 2, Lisa the Iconoclast, Bart Sells His Soul
    Season 8: The Itchy & Scratchy & Poochie Show, The Springfield Files, The Secret War of Lisa Simpson
    Season 9: Girly Edition, The Cartridge Family, Lisa the Skeptic
    Season 10: They Saved Lisa's Brain, Lisa Gets an A, Simpsons Bible Stories
    Season 11: Grift of the Magi, Brother's Little Helper, Beyond Blunderdome
    Season 12: Hungry Hungry Homer, The Computer Wore Menace Shoes, Trilogy of Error
    Season 13: The Bart Wants What It Wants, Poppa's Got a Brand New Badge, Sweets and Sour Marge
    Season 14: I'm Spelling As Fast As I Can, The Bart of War, Mr. Spritz Goes to Washington
    Season 15: Milhouse Doesn't Live Here Anymore, Tis the Fifteenth Season, The Wandering Juvie
    Season 16: Thank God It's Doomsday, The Heartbroke Kid, Fat Man and Little Boy
    Season 17: The Seemingly Never-Ending Story, Marge's Son Poisoning, Bart Has Two Mommies
    Season 18: The Haw-Hawed Couple, 24 Minutes, Little Big Girl
    Season 19: The Debarted, Midnight Towboy, Eternal Moonshine of the Simpson Mind
    Season 20: Gone Maggie Gone, Take My Life Please, Homer and Lisa Exchange Cross Words

  24. #24
    Junior Camper
    Join Date
    May 2003
    Posts
    171


    I liked this one a lot, still thought the middle one was the weakest, a little slow, but Fran's lines were funny and probably even funnier if you never heard her before. Richard Lewis was OK.
    The opening was really well animated and looked like they might have done some Futrama 3d on, the steps at least.
    War of the Worlds was good and yes Big Band Stu needs to be new figure.

  25. #25
    think less drink more Matt B.'s Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2005
    Location
    Bourbon Street
    Posts
    2,427


    4/5 The last one was the best





  26. #26


    3/5 C+

    Pretty good episode. I liked it. The best since Treehouse of Horror XIV.

    The Blob- C+ (damn you Al Jean and your music montages... but I loved the ending, funny, didn't expect it)

    Golem- C- (Meh, the weakest of the three)

    Looked Stupid- B ( Some funny jokes in here: Sound FX guy, "didn't eat the skin, that's healthy" etc. The Iraq 'parody' was unnecessary and forced. Some lameness but overall a decent segment.)

  27. #27
    Virgin Colada! *No Rum breadharrity's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2005
    Location
    NJ
    Posts
    485


    The line they (yay!) cut out was - this sure is alot like what Iraq will be. It was at the end when they cut out to the destroyed town. It seemed like it worked alot better (the aired version tonight)

  28. #28
    Mad without power
    Join Date
    May 2005
    Location
    Lost in the back of my mind
    Posts
    873


    Yay, I can finally post my full review, even though the episode hasn't legally aired where I live yet. :P

    Intro is pretty funny and very well-animated, aside from Moe asking Smithers to ram the spikes in more. Now for each individual segment:

    Married to the Blob
    The strongest of the stories, if you ask me. While it doesn't try to be that scary, it doesn't try to be sappy either. (People need to remember that some of the best Halloween stories, like "Time and Punishment", aren't scary at all.) The deaths are pretty funny, and I honestly don't think the Dr. Phil appearance is that bad. I mean, at least he gets killed. I think everyone wants to see Dr. Phil get killed. Sure beats the Terry Bradshaw appearance in "Surivival of the Fattest". It also ends on a great humorous note, rather than trying to end on an emotional one with Marge simply living with the gargantuan Homer. Downside...musical montage. Far more out-of-place than the guest star appearance, if you ask me. B

    You Gotta Know When to Golem
    Putrid. This is Halloween-esque HOW? I mean, at least the Blob segment spoofed an old movie. This was similar to "Frinkenstein", but even worse. The Golem was an uninteresting and lame character. The female Golem was even worse. Didn't Jean realize that adding emotion in a Halloween episode is what made last year's bomb? (Then again, he doesn't realize a lot of things) Really, Homer's drunk moment was the only think that saved this from being the worst segment since "Hex and the City". Total shit. D+

    The Day the Earth Stood Stupid
    So very very glad they cut the line at the end, but I still think the satire is way too obvious with lines such as "weapons of mass disintigration" and the whole "three years later" thing. Really, the Iraq stuff felt tacked on to an otherwise fairly solid segment. The music and animation were superb, and the jokes before the mud scene were pretty humorous and hit the mark ("Why do you keep saying first World War?"). Also, how could you not have a Kang & Kodos appearance in a ThoH segment without maniacal laughing that lasts pointlessly for ten seconds? I originally gave this a C+, but since they apparantly cut the last line, I'll give it a B-.

    B- overall.

    (By comparison, the last 3 years' Treehouses all got C's or C+'s from me)
    Season 19 Ratings - Now More Bitter Than Ever!
    He Loves to Fly and He D'ohs -

  29. #29
    Filthy Repulsive Anteater Mr_Scorpion's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2006
    Location
    Salt Lake City, UT
    Posts
    925


    Married To The Blob - Good segment that was executed pretty much exactly like I thought it would be. It had quite a few great moments (Arby's, the barbeque sauce fight), but the Dr. Phil cameo and yet another music montage killed any atmosphere they had built. Giant Lenny and invisible Carl got the biggest laugh of the night, though. 3/5

    You Gotta Know When To Golem - Just like the first segment, they built a creepy atmosphere and then promptly abandoned it. Still, it showed some creativity, which is more than I can say for any of last year's segments. They didn't go the way of "the golem attacks random characters for ten minutes" like I thought they would, so I was pleasantly surprised. 3/5

    The Day The Earth Looked Stupid - Second only to "The Ned Zone" as the best post-classic era segment, IMO. I loved the atmosphere and the animation. Maurice LaMarche did a great job, and for once there were no blatantly bad jokes. With the Iraq line cut out, I'm giving this a 4/5.

    So, overall... 4/5. Best episode of the season so far. Never thought I'd say that about a THOH again!

  30. #30
    AddminisGator Gatorgod's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2005
    Location
    Swamptopia
    Posts
    12,757


    4/5 ..Great Halloween show. The sea Capt's lost his head again this year, and the lack of continuity always allows Moe to be more violent than usual. Good times!




Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

User Tag List

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •