(Users Browsing this Thread: )
also, noone honestly rates new episodes by the same criteria as the old episodes. people that say they do are liars. dirty liars.
Season 21 ratings (A.K.A. Qwert's Generic Sig Vol. II)
Homer The Whopper 7/10 Bart Gets A 'Z' 8.5/10 The Great Wife Hope 9/10 Treehouse Of Horror XX 9.17/10
The Devil Wears Nada 9.5/10 Pranks And Greens 6.5/10 Rednecks And Broomsticks 7.5/10 Oh Brother, Where Bart Thou? 8.5/10
Thursdays With Abie 5.5/10 Once Upon A Time In Springfield 10/10 Million Dollar Maybe 4.5/10 Boy Meets Curl 6/10
The Color Yellow 9/10 Postcards From The Wedge 9.5/10
Besides, who are we to speculate on others' intent?
60 Second Simpsons - Ep32 - And Maggie Makes Three
Quite a dull episode, and as mentioned many times before, the whole Homer committing suicide is a bit depressing. Although the characters were not as developed and loved as they are now.
Edit : Woops.
Last edited by Blobulle; 10-30-2011 at 01:17 AM. Reason: Already posted in this thread.
weird. even if it is season 1 Homer campaigning for safety feels very odd. Starts off well with the first act but goes down hill with the surprisingly extreme suicide scene and the boredom of Homer's safety antics. Lacks the emotional resonance of the best S1 episodes but has some amusing moments and an alright first act. C (3/5)
- It's safe to ssey, this episode isn't all that -
Okay, that pun was terrible. 'Homer's Odyssey' is one of those episodes from the classic era that isn't liked a lot. I had heard a lot of bad things about it when I sat down and watched it today, so wasn't entirely positive. However, until today, I hadn't seen it in years, so it would have been wrong to go in based on others views. So, was it as bad as others made it appear?
Well, it wasn't that great - it's probably one of the lesser classics. Yet I'd be making myself hate it, if I gave it a 1/5. The episode actually starts off quite well. There are a number of funny moments, and on a personal level, I can relate with Wendell 'cos I was that kid, always throwing up on bus/coach journeys. However, the episode quickly fell apart after Homer's abrupt firing. The next part felt kind of dull, but I'm not going to describe it much, because I can't really remember what happened (and I just watched it today - either I'm going senile, or the episode gets quite forgettable). Homer was likeable in this part, I guess, so that was okay. Then comes the part of this episode that everyone hates. Homer tries to kill himself. I'm going to agree with the majority here and say, yeah, that was bad. Firstly, suicide should never be done in the show. It didn't work in 'Hello Gutter, Hello Fadder' (too zany for something serious like suicide), it didn't work in 'Million Dollar Abie' (just felt forced, and out of place), and it didn't work here. It mainly didn't work here because it just felt overly dark, and strange to do, considering this was only the third episode of the show. Also, Homer's decision to commit suicide didn't feel right. In 'I Married Marge', when he was unable to provide for the family, he left Marge and worked in a minimum wage job to help her. He didn't resort to suicide. I know we are shown Homer being rejected from a number of jobs in this episode, but it's difficult to believe that he couldn't get even the most meagre job. I'm sort of nitpicking here, but I just didn't like how his depression was handled here. So after moping around, attempting suicide, then being found by his family (with a quite clunky emotional scene), Homer decides to campaign for safety. I don't know, but his sudden epiphany felt really strange, and quite forced. Homer's campaign for the last 5 minutes or so, was rather dull. Then Homer gets a new job at the plant, and there we go. Episode finished.
I realise by the sound of my review, it sounds like I hated 'Homer's Odyssey', but I didn't really. It's certaintly one of the lesser classics, and once I watch the rest of Season 1, it may go further down in my opinion. However, this episode didn't really feel all that awful. The suicide bit was stupid, some bits were quite dull - and I'd also like to add that the animation was poor in numerous parts (moreso than other episodes around this time - the mouths were weird, crowd scenes were shoddy, and some of the backgrounds weren't great). Still, I think this episode may be good enough to get a 3/5. Maybe that will change, maybe it won't.
+ Homer was likeable, I guess
+ Started off strongly
- Suicide is a Simpsons no-no
- The episode was boring in parts
- The animation was dodgy
Poochie needs to be louder, angrier, and have access to a time machine
I wouldn't really point it out on other episodes in Season 1, and it's understandable that the animation wouldn't be at its best, but the animation in this one stuck out - possibly due to the number of crowd scenes.
Season 1 at its weakest. The story is very emotional, but Homer wanting to kill himself felt heavy-handed. Other than giving Homer his series long occupation as Nuclear Safety Inspector, this episode doesn't add much to the show.
Highlights include Bart singing 'John Henry was a Steel Drivin' Man', nuclear education video, Homer's line "Beer, there's a temporary solution", Bart's prank phone call(I.P. Freely), the composite sketch of El Barto and Mr.Burn's line "You're not as stupid as you look, or sound, or our best testing indicates".
Last edited by Lionel Hutz; 06-06-2012 at 04:21 PM.
If you were actually old enough to see this in it's original viewing you wouldn't give it less than 3/5.
I think Homers suicide attempt was totally in character and would lay the ground work for his selfishness for the next 25 seasons, I mean what one thing has Homer ever done that was more selfish and arrogant than trying to kill himself?
Sucide is the ultimate form of selfishness, so please don't post same lame example like Homer locking Bart in a bunny cage was worse, b/c it is simply not.
By far Homer trying to kill himself was the height of 'Jerk-Ass Homer' or whatever you guys call him in later seasons, and this was season one.
'Sucide is the ultimate form of selfishness'
I actually meant to write Homer's suicide is the ultimate form of selfishness.
I not going to debate anyone on mere suicide alone, this is not the place for that, and anyway is a case by case basis I suspose.
Another classic. This one is jokes-light even by season 1 standards. There are very funny moments, though, like Homer carrying the boulder to the bridge to kill himself only to find another boulder there when he arrives, and the "killing myself would be the last thing I'd do" line. However, the story and character work is very good. The characters, Homer in this case, are so "human-like" in their feelings and reactions... this grounded style is a trademark of season 1, and I love it. I liked the plot device of having Homer become a safety advocate. It's funny because it's true: there are people like that. The ending, with Homer's negotiations with Mr. Burns, is memorable.
Last edited by db105; 04-19-2012 at 04:03 PM.
Awesome third act is all I can say really. The second act was horrid, while the first was decent. And it originates as the first time we see Homer becoming SNPP safety inspector
7.4/10 or 3.7/5 rounded to a 4
[SIZE=1] Check out my South Park episode ideas in my user notes (Note: It's the fifth and last note): http://www.nohomers.net/usernote.php...ewuser&u=41294
"I got blisters on me fingers!" ~ Ringo Starr (Helter Skelter)
Led Zeppelin IV > Houses of the Holy > Physical Graffiti > Led Zeppelin II > Led Zeppelin I > Led Zeppelin III > Presence > In Through the Out Door > Coda
I certainly won't begrudge anyone liking this episode, but I just am not excited by this one. Sorry. 5.5/10
Pretty bad episode FOR season 1 standards. Sure the animation was terrible and Homer trying to kill himself was stupid and out-of-character, but this was the THIRD episode for the entire series and the animation was made by Klasky Csupo and this was before they animated Rugrats. I think if they did this episode in season 2 or 3 it will be better but sadly, it was made in season 1 so unless they do remakes, we'll never see how good this episode could be. Rating: 3/5 I like Mr. Burns' voice in this episode he actually sound intimidating instead of a old British man.
Also, BLACK SMITHERS!!