Best Scully holdovers

[Nameless]

Basically, a clone of the Jean holdover thread, only with Scully

Season 9 Episodes Held Back Into Season 10 (5Fs-AABFs)
Lard of the Dance: 3/5
The Wizard of Evergreen Terrace: 3.5/5
Bart, the Mother: 4/5
When You Dish Upon A Star: 2/5

Overall: Aside from the great Bart the Mother, nothing really good here.

Season 10 Episodes Held Back Into Season 11 (AABFs-BABFs)
Beyond Blunderdome: 2/5
Brother's Little Helper: 2/5
Guess Who's Coming To Criticize Dinner: 5/5
E-I-E-I-(ANNOYED GRUNT): 3/5

Overall: One good episode among a sea of the bad.

Season 11 Episodes Held Back Into Season 12 (BABFs-CABFs)
Treehouse of Horror XI: 3.5/5
A Tale of Two Springfields: 3/5
Insane Clown Poppy: 3/5
HOMR: 5/5

Overall: Save HOMR, nothing great here...again

Season 12 Episodes Held Back Into Season 13 (CABFs-DABFs, Non Scully Era)
Treehouse of Horror XII: 3/5
The Parent Rap: 3/5
Homer the Moe: 1/5
A Hunka Hunka Burns In Love: 3/5
The Blunder Years: 2/5

Overall: ugh

Difficult to choose, but I guess S11 held back into S12.

[Dr. Bartley]

Season 12 episodes held back into Season 13

[zomit]

season 9 held back into 10

[Butters]

Season 9 Episodes Held Back Into Season 10 (5Fs-AABFs)
Lard of the Dance - C+
The Wizard of Evergreen Terrace - B+
Bart, the Mother - B
When You Dish Upon A Star - D+

Season 10 Episodes Held Back Into Season 11 (AABFs-BABFs)
Beyond Blunderdome - B
Brother's Little Helper - C-
Guess Who's Coming To Criticize Dinner - A-
E-I-E-I-(ANNOYED GRUNT) - D+

Season 11 Episodes Held Back Into Season 12 (BABFs-CABFs)
Treehouse of Horror XI - B-
A Tale of Two Springfields - C-
Insane Clown Poppy - B-
HOMR - B

Season 12 Episodes Held Back Into Season 13 (CABFs-DABFs, Non Scully Era)
Treehouse of Horror XII - D-
The Parent Rap - C-
Homer the Moe - C+
A Hunka Hunka Burns In Love - C+
The Blunder Years - C-

[Paul]

Season 10:
Lard of the Dance - 4/5
The Wizard of Evergreen Terrace - 4/5
Bart the Mother - 4/5
When You Dish Upon a Star - 2/5

Seaspm 11:
Beyond Blunderdome - 3/5
Brother's Little Helper - 3/5
Guess Who's Coming To Criticize Dinner - 3.5/5
E-I-E-I-(Annoyed Grunt) - 3.5/5

Season 12:
Treehouse of Horror XI - 3.5/5
A Tale of Two Springfields - 3/5
Insane Clown Poppy - 3/5
HOMR - 3.5/5

Season 13:
Treehouse of Horror XII - 3/5
The Parent Rap - 2/5
Homer the Moe - 2/5
A Hunka Hunka Burns In Love - 2.5/5
The Blunder Years - 2.5/5

[deshem]

Season 9 Episodes Held Back Into Season 10
Lard of the Dance - C+
The Wizard of Evergreen Terrace - B+
Bart, the Mother - B+
When You Dish Upon A Star - C-

Season 10 Episodes Held Back Into Season 11
Beyond Blunderdome - C
Brother's Little Helper - D+
Guess Who's Coming To Criticize Dinner - B+
E-I-E-I-(ANNOYED GRUNT) - B-

Season 11 Episodes Held Back Into Season 12 (BABFs-CABFs)
Treehouse of Horror XI - B-
A Tale of Two Springfields - C-
Insane Clown Poppy - C+
HOMR - B-

Season 12 Episodes Held Back Into Season 13 (CABFs-DABFs, Non Scully Era)
Treehouse of Horror XII - D-
The Parent Rap - C+
Homer the Moe - F
A Hunka Hunka Burns In Love - C+
The Blunder Years - B-

Season 9 Episodes Held Back Into Season 10 wins.

[Drunk Barney]

Season 9 into 10.

[California Prunes]

Season 10:
Lard of the Dance - B
The Wizard of Evergreen Terrace - B-
Bart the Mother - B+
When You Dish Upon a Star - D+

Seaspm 11:
Beyond Blunderdome - C-
Brother's Little Helper - D
Guess Who's Coming To Criticize Dinner - B+
E-I-E-I-(Annoyed Grunt) - B-

Season 12:
Treehouse of Horror XI - B-
A Tale of Two Springfields - C-
Insane Clown Poppy - B-
HOMR - B

Season 13:
Treehouse of Horror XII - B-
The Parent Rap - C-
Homer the Moe - D
A Hunka Hunka Burns In Love - C+
The Blunder Years - B-

Season 9 into Season 10 although neither of these holdovers as a whole are very impressive.

[Galalimit]

The season 9 episodes held back until season 10.

[SLH]

Season 10:
Lard of the Dance B-
The Wizard of Evergreen Terrace B+
Bart the Mother B+
When You Dish Upon a Star D-

Season 11:
Beyond Blunderdome D+
Brother's Little Helper B-
Guess Who's Coming To Criticize Dinner B
E-I-E-I-(Annoyed Grunt) C+

Season 12:
Treehouse of Horror XI C
A Tale of Two Springfields D+
Insane Clown Poppy C+
HOMR B+

Season 13:
Treehouse of Horror XII C+
The Parent Rap C-
Homer the Moe D
A Hunka Hunka Burns In Love C
The Blunder Years C+

Um... Season 10

[Handsome Peter]

All 4 Season 11 holdovers were better than average by S11 standards. The Season 12 holdovers were a mixed bag for me, while the S9/S10 holdovers were both mediocre by my standards. S11 holdovers win.

[neoballmon]

Season 12 holdovers

[Jayrayman]

Season 10
Lard of the Dance: 4/5
The Wizard of Evergreen Terrace: 4/5
Bart, the Mother: 3.5/5
When You Dish Upon A Star: 4/5

Season 11
Beyond Blunderdome: 4.5/5 (Im probably the only one who realy liked this episode)
Brother's Little Helper: 2.5/5
Guess Who's Coming To Criticize Dinner: 4.5/5
E-I-E-I-(ANNOYED GRUNT): 4/5

Season 12
Treehouse of Horror XI: 3.5/5
A Tale of Two Springfields: 4/5
Insane Clown Poppy: 3/5
HOMR: 3.5/5

Season 13
Treehouse of Horror XII: 2.5/5 (Probably the worst treehouse of horror)
The Parent Rap: 2/5
Homer the Moe: 2/5
A Hunka Hunka Burns In Love: 3/5
The Blunder Years: 2/5

[Garp]

Season 10:
Lard of the Dance B
The Wizard of Evergreen Terrace C+
Bart the Mother C+
When You Dish Upon a Star B-

Season 11:
Beyond Blunderdome C-
Brother's Little Helper B
Guess Who's Coming To Criticize Dinner B-
E-I-E-I-(Annoyed Grunt) A-

Season 12:
Treehouse of Horror XI B
A Tale of Two Springfields B-
Insane Clown Poppy B-
HOMR D-

Season 13:
Treehouse of Horror XII B+
The Parent Rap B-
Homer the Moe B
A Hunka Hunka Burns In Love B-
The Blunder Years B-


Season 13