R + R: The War of the Simpsons

[Starbucks Exec]

Overall, a good episode, but wasn't as emotional as it perhaps should have been. The party scenes I enjoyed. Dr. Hibbert got some good lines. Homer trying to sneak into church unnoticed was a hoot. The scenes at Catfish Lake however seemed a little half-hearted. Reverend Lovejoy's voice was also off. The Bart/Lisa/Abe subplot was the best part, but the main laugh came at the end with Abe's little trick. Overall, a tricky episode to judge, but as I got my evening's worth of quality entertainment from it I'll give it a 'B'.

[Starbucks Exec]

Oopsie, forgot to incude the poll bit. Now that I come to mention it, I can't find the poll button. Help please?

[SideshowTim]

You can only add a poll the first time you post it, You can't go back and edit and put in a poll. Moderators can though they will put one in for you.

A very good Homer/Marge marriage problems episode and one of the funnier episodes from season 2. 8.5/10

[pat]

Agreed. 9/10

[Rnymd]

great episode, i especially like the ending - A-

[Wezzo]

A Underrated.

[George Cauldron]

This is regarded by most people as a weak episode by the standards of season two. I, however, disagree. It's a strong episode that holds its own and has some absolutely hilarious moments. Everyone, again, is in character and there are no wacky or stupid moments for the sake of it, although I can understand how people understandably cringe at the winking catfish at the end. Nevertheless, a great episode.

[Generic]

9/10. I prefer it to "Secrets of a Successful Marriage" and other "Homer and Marge's marriage on the rocks" episodes.

I can understand how people understandably cringe at the winking catfish at the end.

That's balanced out by Homer's vision of Catfish Marge. ;)

[HomertheGreat]

I'm one of those people that thinks it's one of the weaker ones of Season 2. There are some great scenes like Homer recalling the party night (excellent animation), the babysitter remembering Bart, the party, and Grandpa tricking the kids at the end. The problem was the counseling part of the episode, it just seemed kind of pointless, it seemed that it revolved more around Homer trying to catch the big fish than Homer and Marge trying to save their marriage. B/B-

[Garp]

I like it. It gets a 10/10 for me. Probably the 2nd or the 3rd best of season 2.

[Mr. Plow]

Be sure at the end of your post to click for Yes! Post a poll.

And I give this episode a 4/5.

[Channel Surfer]

Grade: B

As a "serious" episode examining Homer and Marge's relationship, it falls a bit short. While I understand that Homer throwing the fish away was supposed to be a symbolic gesture (at least in Marge's eyes) represent that he cares more about their marriage then keeping a prized fish, there's little in the way of insight or depth revealed about their marriage, other then really Homer cares about their marriage. It's not so much directionless or pointless as it is basic. On the plus side the humor is strong enough, particularly in the Bart/Lisa/Grampa party subplot, but also in the main plot with other people at the retreat (Ned and Maude and the other couple), the opening with Homer and Marge's own party, and even the often despised fisherman story about Homer at the end. Fun, and sometimes underrated, but still not anything special.

[y2dave2004]

2/5 nothing special.

[Air Homer]

I think it's a pretty funny episode 9/10

[Fox Executive]

4/5

[Moe Nopoly]

a really entertaining episode with Marge and Homer.
I like the story and it provides some great moments.
Not really a great episodes by all means, but not bad either
and i like it, has no downside for me.

B

[Generic]

It's funny to think that this episode contained elements I've disliked in recent years; Homer and Marge fighting and being forced to deal with problems in their relationship that is ultimately solved when Homer makes a grand gesture. I guess back then, that plot was much fresher but it was also done so much better with the characters being much more sympathetic, the conflict not at all contrived and some really good jokes. It also has an enjoyable subplot with the kids scheming to take advantage of Abe only to have him turn the tables on them. I'll stand by my previous grade, though I guess I'd adjust it to 4.5/5.

[sconer]

Pretty good, but the marriage crisis felt rushed and there is better marriage crisis episodes. Still, a good episode. 4/5.

[The Sovereign]

The beginning is amazing
"Not THOSE peanuts...the ones at the bottom..."

5/5

[ThatAsianGuy]

not bad, 4.5/5